Which Wich Secret Menu Guide 2026
The Which Wich secret menu is not an official menu. It is the bag ordering system: you mark up a bag with your base sandwich, bread, cheeses, toppings and paid extras, so off-menu combos are custom builds. Expect a 7-inch base plus about $1 per extra like bacon or avocado and $2 for double meat, with prices varying by location. If you came here from the full Which Wich menu with prices, this guide shows you how to turn that regular menu into something that feels off-menu.
Does Which Wich Have a Secret Menu?
No, Which Wich does not publish an official secret menu. What fans call the which wich secret menu is a set of custom builds made through the normal ordering system, and honestly, that is what makes it fun.
Here is how it works. You grab a brown paper bag printed with the menu, take a red Sharpie, and mark your picks: a base sandwich from one of the ten categories, a size, bread, cheeses, spreads and toppings. The crew builds exactly what you marked.
That also means two things worth knowing up front. First, nothing here is a guaranteed item. Second, paid extras add up fast, so always confirm the upcharge before they toast it.
What Are the Best Which Wich Secret Menu Items?
The best which wich secret menu items start from real menu bases and add one or two bold twists. These seven builds use ingredients every location already stocks, so they are the most likely to work. Prices below cover the extras only, since base prices vary by location.
| Build | Start With | Say This | Extra Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Double Wicked | The Wicked (5 meats, 3 cheeses) | “Wicked, double meat, double cheese, extra bacon, toasted.” | ~$4 |
| Buffalo Wicked | The Wicked | “Wicked with buffalo sauce, pepper jack, jalapenos and ranch.” | ~$0-$1 |
| Philly Melt Deluxe | Phillywich | “Phillywich, double meat, double provolone, caramelized onions, mushrooms, chipotle mayo.” | ~$3 |
| Breakfast Anytime Wich | Build-your-own egg base | “Sliced egg, bacon, cheddar and avocado on toasted white, hot.” | ~$2 |
| Skinny Wicked Bowl | The Wicked | “Wicked as a bowl, no bread, extra lettuce, tomato and cucumber, balsamic.” | ~$0 |
| Pizzawich Supreme | Pizzawich | “Pizzawich, double cheese, extra marinara, banana peppers, oregano.” | ~$1 |
| Sweet Heat Chicken | Buffalo Chicken | “Buffalo chicken, honey mustard, pepper jack, jalapenos and avocado.” | ~$1 |
A quick note on the Double Wicked. It is the most famous fan build, but it is a lot of sandwich. If you are not feeding two people, order it in the regular 7-inch size first.
How Do You Order From the Which Wich Secret Menu?
Ordering which wich secret menu builds in store is easy once you know the bag routine. Follow these steps and you will not hold up the line.
Step by Step
1. Pick a base. Start with a real menu sandwich like the Wicked, Phillywich, Buffalo Chicken or Pizzawich. The crew knows these, so your build has a clear starting point.
2. Mark the size and bread. Regular is 7 inches, Large is 10.5 inches, Super is 14 inches. You can also pick a lettucewich, spinach wrap or bowl. White and wheat are the standard breads.
3. Mark cheeses and toppings. Most toppings are free, so this is where the fun lives. Keep it to a handful of flavors that go together instead of marking everything on the bag.
4. Mark paid extras. Double meat, double cheese, bacon, avocado and sliced egg are the usual paid extras. Check the extras box on the bag and ask the price if it is not printed.
5. Hand over the bag and confirm. Say the build name out loud, like “Double Wicked, toasted,” and ask, “What does that add?” before they start. A ten-second check beats a surprise at the register.
Two tips from regulars. Go easy during the lunch rush, and if a location says they cannot do a build, do not argue.
How Much Does the Which Wich Secret Menu Cost?
Which wich secret menu prices depend on two things: your base sandwich and how many paid extras you add. Most toppings, sauces and veggies are free. The paid extras are where the bill moves.
| Extra | Typical Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Double meat | ~$2 | The biggest single upcharge, and the one that changes the sandwich most. |
| Double cheese | ~$1 | Pick one cheese to double so flavors stay clean. |
| Bacon | ~$1 | Adds salt and crunch to almost any build. |
| Avocado | ~$1 | Fresh avocado, great on chicken and turkey builds. |
| Sliced egg | ~$1 | The key to breakfast-style builds. |
These extra prices come from posted location menus and vary by franchise, so treat them as a guide, not a promise. Base sandwich prices vary even more, and delivery apps usually charge more than in-store.
One more money saver: size up only when you mean it. A Large is about 50 percent longer than a Regular, and a Super doubles it.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does Which Wich have a secret menu?
No official one. The which wich secret menu is a set of fan-made custom builds ordered through the regular bag system, using real menu ingredients, free toppings and paid extras.
How do I order a Which Wich secret menu item?
Mark a base sandwich on the paper bag, then mark your size, bread, cheeses, toppings and paid extras. Tell the crew the build name, like “Double Wicked,” and confirm the upcharge before they toast it.
How much extra do secret menu customizations cost?
Most toppings are free. Paid extras typically run about $1 each for double cheese, bacon, avocado or sliced egg, and about $2 for double meat, though prices vary by location.
Can I order secret menu builds online or on delivery apps?
In-store ordering works best, because the bag system gives you full control. Delivery listings usually show the standard menu with limited custom options, so a complex build may not come out the way you pictured it.
Prices last verified: October 13, 2026. Prices vary by location, so confirm extras at your store. Source: Which Wich official site.
🔗 Related Reading
So that is the whole which wich secret menu: no hidden board, just a bag, a red marker, and a little creativity. Start with a Wicked or a Phillywich, add one or two extras, and you have a sandwich nobody else in line is eating.
