Five Guys Secret Menu Guide 2026
There is no official Five Guys secret menu, but there might as well be. Everything is cooked to order with 15 free toppings, so the staff know every off-menu hack by heart. This guide covers the 8 best hacks: what to say, what each costs, and the one ordering rule that matters most.
Is the Five Guys Secret Menu Real?
No, not officially. Five Guys has never printed a secret menu or taught cashiers code names. But that hardly matters. Since the kitchen builds every burger from scratch and toppings cost nothing, anything you can describe can be made. The five guys secret menu is really a fan-made list of custom builds that regulars have ordered for years. New here? Skim the full Five Guys menu with prices first, then come back for the fun stuff.
What Is on the Five Guys Secret Menu? The 8 Best Hacks
These come up again and again in Reddit threads and food blogs. Every one uses real Five Guys ingredients, which is why the staff can actually make them.
1. Double Grilled Cheeseburger
The big one. A beef patty between TWO grilled cheese sandwiches instead of a bun. Say: “Two grilled cheeses, with a beef patty in the middle, dressed how I like.” Name your toppings one by one. You pay for two grilled cheeses plus an extra patty, so it is the priciest hack on this list.
2. Patty Melt
Beef patty, grilled onions and melted cheese on toasted bread instead of a bun. Some locations now list the Patty Melt on the regular menu (around $11.85), but many stores still treat it as a custom order. Say: “A patty melt, beef patty with grilled onions and cheese on toasted bread.”
3. Cheese Fries
Not on the board, but real. Ask for cheese melted over your fries. Some locations do it free, others charge about 50 cents. Say: “Can I get cheese melted on my fries?” Well-done fries (see below) stay crispier under the cheese.
4. Well-Done Fries
The simplest hack here and completely free. Ask for your fries “well done” and they get extra time in the peanut oil: darker, crunchier, better. It is also the perfect base for cheese fries or the loaded fries bowl.
5. Loaded Fries Bowl
Order a Little Cheeseburger “in a bowl, chopped, no bun” with toppings on the side, plus a small fry. Dump the fries into the foil container with the chopped burger, mix, and you have loaded fries. Grilled mushrooms and hot sauce are the move.
6. Sloppy Joe Burger
Your usual burger with grilled onions, grilled green peppers, ketchup and BBQ sauce on top. The sweet-savory mix tastes remarkably like a sloppy joe. All four are free toppings, so this one adds zero dollars.
7. Bacon Milkshake
Sounds like a prank, tastes like genius. Shakes start from a vanilla base with 10 permanent mix-ins, including bacon, Oreo cookies, peanut butter and salted caramel. Say: “Vanilla shake with the bacon mix-in.” My take: add Oreo pieces too. You will not regret it.
8. In-a-Bowl Burger
The healthiest hack on the list. Order any burger “in a bowl” and they skip the bun and serve the patty and toppings in a container, basically a burger salad. Same price as the burger you ordered, and the go-to move for low-carb regulars.
How Much Do Five Guys Secret Menu Items Cost?
Most five guys secret menu hacks cost little to nothing extra, because they are built from free toppings or regular menu items. The exceptions are the ones that stack whole menu items.
| Hack | How to Order | Extra Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Double Grilled Cheeseburger | Two grilled cheeses with a beef patty between them | ~$17+ |
| Patty Melt | Beef patty, grilled onions, cheese on toasted bread | ~$11.85 |
| Cheese Fries | Cheese melted over your fries | $0 – $0.50 |
| Well-Done Fries | Ask for fries “well done” | Free |
| Loaded Fries Bowl | Chopped cheeseburger in a bowl over small fries | Burger + fries price |
| Sloppy Joe Burger | Grilled onions, green peppers, ketchup, BBQ sauce | Free |
| Bacon Milkshake | Vanilla shake with the bacon mix-in | $8.05 |
| In-a-Bowl Burger | Any burger “in a bowl,” no bun | Free |
How Do You Order the Five Guys Secret Menu?
Three rules. First, describe the build, not the nickname. “A bacon cheeseburger with a halved hot dog on top” gets you lunch; “I’ll have the Artery Annihilator” gets you a blank stare. Second, keep complicated orders away from the lunch and dinner rush. Third, expect some variation: not every location will chop a patty for your loaded fries bowl, and that is fine.
Cashiers handle picky custom orders all day, so “fries well done” or “cheese melted on the fries” is nothing new to them. Be specific, be friendly, and you will be fine.
Five Guys Secret Menu FAQs
Is the Five Guys secret menu real?
There is no official Five Guys secret menu printed anywhere. It is a fan-made collection of off-menu custom builds, like the Double Grilled Cheeseburger and the Patty Melt, that staff can make because everything is cooked to order and toppings are free.
How do you order from the Five Guys secret menu?
Describe the exact build instead of using a nickname. Say “two grilled cheeses with a beef patty in the middle” rather than asking for a “Double Grilled Cheeseburger.” Name your toppings one by one, and avoid complicated orders during the rush.
How much does the Five Guys double grilled cheeseburger cost?
Expect roughly $17 or more, since you pay for two grilled cheeses plus an extra beef patty. Prices vary by location. It is the priciest hack on this list because you are stacking whole menu items.
Does Five Guys charge extra for secret menu items?
Usually not much. Hacks built from free toppings (Sloppy Joe burger, well-done fries, cheese fries) cost little or nothing extra. You only pay more when the hack combines whole menu items, like the Double Grilled Cheeseburger.
📚 Related Reading
Prices last verified: 2026-10-12. Official menu source: Five Guys official menu. Secret menu prices are estimates based on regular menu item prices, since off-menu builds are priced from their components.
