Whit’s Frozen Custard Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the Whit’s Frozen Custard Menu, then you landed at the right place. Here, you can easily explore the Whit’s Frozen Custard Menu with prices along with full details and photos. All prices are researched from official shop menus and updated for 2026. Whit’s is a Midwest legend: rich, dense frozen custard made fresh in every single shop, every single day. No warehouse tubs, no pre-frozen mix. And trust me, once you taste custard that was churned this morning, regular ice cream tastes like a sad memory of dessert.
🍦 What Do Frozen Custard Quarts Cost at Whit’s?
A quart of Whit’s frozen custard costs about $11.00 at most shops in 2026, with prices ranging from $8.00 to $14.50 depending on the location. Here’s the thing most first-timers miss: every Whit’s makes its custard fresh daily, and there’s always a Flavor of the Week on top of the standbys. Some shops post the daily and weekly flavors on a chalkboard out front. I check it like it’s the news.
| Flavor | Details | Price (Quart) | Calories* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla | The classic, dense and silky, made fresh every morning | $11.00 | ~1,360/qt |
| Chocolate | Rich cocoa custard, deep and fudgy | $11.00 | ~1,440/qt |
| Buckeye | Peanut butter custard swirled with fudge and Reese’s cups, an Ohio rite of passage | $11.00 | ~1,920/qt |
| Penguin Tracks | Caramel, hot fudge and pecans, the shop mascot in flavor form | $11.00 | ~1,880/qt |
| Black Raspberry Chip | Tart black raspberry with dark chocolate chips, cult favorite | $11.00 | ~1,600/qt |
| Sea Salt Caramel | Salty-sweet caramel ribbon through vanilla, owner’s pick at many shops | $11.00 | ~1,760/qt |
| Mint Chocolate Chip | Cool mint with chocolate chips, dangerously easy to eat by the spoonful | $11.00 | ~1,560/qt |
| Butter Pecan | Buttery roasted pecans in vanilla, old-school comfort | $11.00 | ~1,760/qt |
| Almond Joy | Coconut, chocolate and almonds, the candy bar you can scoop | $11.00 | ~1,800/qt |
| Strawberry | Real strawberries folded into vanilla, summer in a container | $11.00 | ~1,440/qt |
| Flavor of the Week | Rotates weekly, from Chocoholic to Key Lime Pie to Peaches ‘n’ Cream | $11.00 | ~1,700/qt |
*Calorie counts are estimates per quart and vary by recipe; ask your local shop for exact numbers.
Why Custard Costs More Than Ice Cream (And Why It’s Worth It)
Honestly, yes, you’ll pay a couple bucks more than a grocery-store tub. Here’s what that buys you: frozen custard has less air churned into it than ice cream, so it’s denser and creamier, and at Whit’s it’s made in-store every day, not shipped from a warehouse. A quart of custard that’s hours old just hits different. That’s not marketing fluff, it’s physics and freshness.
🥪 How Much Are Whitties & Custard Sandwiches at Whit’s?
Whitties cost about $7.00 each at most Whit’s shops in 2026. A Whittie is a thick scoop of custard sandwiched between two fresh-baked cookies, and it’s the item Whit’s is famous for. One of these is genuinely a meal-sized dessert. Custard sandwiches (custard between chocolate wafers) run cheaper at about $5.00.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip Whittie | Vanilla custard between fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies, the bestseller | $7.00 | ~860 |
| Buckeye Whittie | Buckeye custard between chocolate cookies, peanut butter lovers rejoice | $7.00 | ~920 |
| S’mores Whittie | Graham-cookie sandwich with toasted marshmallow custard | $7.00 | ~880 |
| M&M Vanilla Whittie | Vanilla custard and candy-coated chocolate on a sugar cookie base | $7.00 | ~890 |
| Double Dark Chocolate Whittie | Chocolate custard between double-chocolate cookies, full cocoa mode | $7.00 | ~940 |
| Birthday Cake Whittie | Cake-flavored custard with sprinkles between sugar cookies | $7.00 | ~870 |
| Classic Custard Sandwich | Vanilla custard between two chocolate wafers | $5.00 | ~420 |
| Oreo Sandwich | Custard with crushed Oreo-style cookies between wafers | $5.00 | ~480 |
*Estimated per item; varies with cookie size and custard flavor.
The Whittie Strategy
Whitties are the single best value per dollar of pure joy on this menu. But here’s a veteran tip: they also run a Whittie of the Month at many locations, a limited cookie-custard combo you’ll only find by asking. And if you can’t finish one in a sitting (respectable), they travel well in a cooler. They were designed for that.
🍧 What Is the Cheapest Way to Try Whit’s Frozen Custard?
The cheapest items at Whit’s are the brownie for about $2.00 and the doggie sundae (pup cup) for about $2.50. For an actual taste of the custard itself, a cone runs about $4.50, which is the cheapest full-size serving. This is the section for the skeptics, the dog owners, and the “I’ll just have a small bite” crowd (spoiler: it won’t stay small).
| Item | Details | Price | Calories* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Custard Cone | A generous swirl on a cake cone, vanilla or chocolate | $4.50 | ~450 |
| Drumstick | Custard cone dipped in chocolate, with sprinkles or nuts on request | $4.50 | ~520 |
| Whit’s Italian Ice | Dairy-free frozen fruit ice, a lighter pick | $5.00 | ~180 |
| Chocolate Covered Banana | Whole banana dipped in chocolate, add nuts or sprinkles | $4.00 | ~300 |
| Doggie Sundae (Pup Cup) | A small cup of plain custard for your four-legged co-pilot | $2.50 | n/a |
| Fudge Brownie | Warm fudgy brownie, also sold as a mix-in base | $2.00 | ~350 |
*Estimated per item.
🎂 How Much Are Whit’s Frozen Custard Cakes?
Whit’s frozen custard cakes cost about $25.00 for a small and $35.00 for a large in 2026, with specialty cakes like the Buckeye Madness starting around $28.00. Small cakes serve roughly 8 to 10 people, large cakes 12 to 16. If you want a custom flavor combo, call your local shop a couple of days ahead, many shops will build cakes to order with your choice of custard and toppings.
| Item | Details | Price | Serves |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small Custard Cake | Layered custard cake, choice of flavors, serves a small party | $25.00 | 8–10 |
| Large Custard Cake | Bigger build for birthdays and office parties | $35.00 | 12–16 |
| Buckeye Madness Cake | Peanut butter custard, fudge and Reese’s cups, the signature cake | $28.00+ | 10–12 |
| Cookies ‘n’ Cream Cake | Cookie-crumb custard layer cake | $28.00+ | 10–12 |
| Custard Pie | Frozen custard pie, call ahead for available flavors | $15.00 | 6–8 |
Cake Ordering Tips
For Whit’s frozen custard catering prices and party orders, the small cake at $25 is one of the best dessert deals in the whole frozen-dessert world. It feeds ten people for two-fifty a head. Honestly, try feeding ten people dessert at a restaurant for that. The grab-and-go freezers at most shops also carry hand-packed quarts and ready-made cakes if you need something tonight with zero planning.
📊 Nutrition Information
Let’s be real: Whit’s is a treat, not health food. But if you’re watching it, here’s the landscape. Frozen custard runs about 170 to 240 calories per half-cup serving, and mix-in flavors climb from there. Your lightest menu options are the Italian ice (around 180 calories) and the chocolate covered banana (around 300 calories). The pup cup has no business being in your calorie budget discussion.
| Item | Calories (est.) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Whit’s Italian Ice | ~180 | Lowest-calorie menu item, dairy-free |
| Chocolate Covered Banana | ~300 | Fruit plus chocolate, reasonable pick |
| No Sugar Added Vanilla (scoop) | ~140/scoop | Available at many shops, ask locally |
| Custard Cone | ~450 | The classic serving |
| Chocolate Chip Whittie | ~860 | Meal-sized dessert |
| Quart of Buckeye Custard | ~1,920/qt | Highest-calorie popular item, share it |
Whit’s shops also carry no-sugar-added vanilla and, at select locations, vegan vanilla pints, so if dairy is the issue rather than calories, ask what’s in the freezer. Full Whit’s Frozen Custard nutrition info varies by recipe and location, your shop can tell you exactly what’s in today’s batch.
💰 Deals & Money-Saving Tips
Want the full custard experience without paying full price every time? Here’s how regulars do it:
- Download the Whit’s loyalty app. The brand rolled out a new loyalty program app after the 2025 acquisition, and points on every visit add up fast if Whit’s is your regular stop.
- Check Fivestars deals at your local shop. Several Florida locations run standing promos there, like 10% off your first order, and free kids-scoop offers pop up seasonally.
- Look for voucher deals. Some shops have appeared on local deal sites with offers like $10 for $20 worth of custard, half off is the best coupon in frozen dessert.
- Chase the Flavor of the Week. The weekly flavor is priced the same as the classics, so you get limited-edition excitement at zero upcharge. Some weeks are legendary.
- Buy quarts, not cones, for the family. A quart at around $11 scoops into about four servings. That’s under three bucks a serving, cheaper than almost any single item on the board.
- Gift cards for birthdays. Whit’s gift cards are available at most shops and online, and they’re the rare gift card that never sits unused.
🕐 Whit’s Frozen Custard Opening Hours
Most Whit’s Frozen Custard shops open around noon and close between 9PM and 10PM, staying open later on Friday and Saturday nights. Because every shop is independently owned, hours genuinely differ by location, some close for winter, some open earlier for the summer rush. When in doubt, check your local shop’s social media page before you drive over.
| Day | Typical Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday | 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM / 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM |
Typical hours; your local shop may open earlier or close later, especially in summer.
🏪 About Whit’s Frozen Custard
Whit’s Frozen Custard was founded on March 3, 2003, by Chuck and Lisa Whitman in Granville, Ohio, after Chuck spent years perfecting his frozen custard recipe. The first little shop opened on Prospect Street, moved to Broadway nine months later, and the original Granville store is still scooping today. In 2025 the franchise system was acquired by Space Cowboys Restaurant Group (CEO Bill Aseere), the headquarters moved to Independence, Kentucky, and the brand got a refreshed logo and a new loyalty app. As of 2026, Whit’s runs 103 locations across 10 U.S. states: Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and West Virginia. The formula never changed: custard made fresh in every shop, every day, with a rotating Flavor of the Week that keeps the regulars coming back like clockwork.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular item at Whit’s Frozen Custard?
The Chocolate Chip Whittie (about $7.00) is the icon of the menu, a giant custard cookie sandwich that most regulars order on autopilot. The Buckeye quart is the #1 take-home seller at many shops. If it’s your first visit, start with one of these two and you can’t go wrong.
What is the cheapest item on the Whit’s Frozen Custard menu?
The cheapest items at Whit’s Frozen Custard are the fudge brownie for about $2.00 and the doggie sundae (pup cup) for about $2.50. The cheapest full-size custard serving is the custard cone at about $4.50.
How much does a quart of Whit’s frozen custard cost?
A quart of Whit’s frozen custard costs about $11.00 at most locations in 2026, though prices range from $8.00 to $14.50 depending on the shop. Quarts are hand-packed fresh and come in every flavor the shop is churning that day, including the Flavor of the Week.
What is the flavor of the week at Whit’s Frozen Custard?
The Flavor of the Week rotates every seven days and is set by each shop, past hits include Chocoholic, Key Lime Pie, Peaches ‘n’ Cream, Thin Mint and Sugar Cookie Madness. Follow your local Whit’s shop on social media to see this week’s flavor before you go.
Does Whit’s Frozen Custard deliver?
Yes, many Whit’s locations offer delivery through DoorDash, and some shops are DashPass eligible with $0 delivery fees. Note that delivery menu prices are often higher than in-store prices, and quarts, Whitties and novelties travel best.
Can I order a Whit’s custard cake for a birthday party?
Absolutely. Small custard cakes run about $25.00 (serves 8–10) and large cakes about $35.00 (serves 12–16), with the signature Buckeye Madness starting around $28.00. Call your shop a day or two ahead for custom flavors, and check the grab-and-go freezer for ready-made cakes if you need one tonight.
Does Whit’s Frozen Custard have dairy-free or sugar-free options?
Yes. Many shops carry no-sugar-added vanilla, select locations offer vegan vanilla pints, and the Italian ice is always dairy-free and the lowest-calorie item on the menu at around 180 calories. Availability varies by shop, so ask locally.
Does Whit’s have a rewards app or coupons?
Yes, Whit’s launched a new loyalty program app with the 2025 brand refresh, and many shops run extra promos through Fivestars (like 10% off your first order) or local deal sites. Your best move: download the app and follow your local shop’s page for weekly flavor drops and seasonal deals.
What is the difference between frozen custard and ice cream?
Two big differences: frozen custard is made fresh daily in the shop (ice cream is made in a warehouse, frozen and shipped), and custard has less air churned in, making it denser, creamier and richer than ice cream. It also traditionally contains egg yolk, which adds to the silky texture.
Are Whit’s Frozen Custard prices the same at every location?
No. Whit’s shops are independently owned and prices vary by location, the national averages in this article reflect 2026 pricing, but your shop’s menu may run a little higher or lower. Prices last verified: October 12, 2026. Check the brand’s official site (whitsfrozencustard.com) and your local shop’s posted menu for exact prices.
📍 Find Whit’s Frozen Custard Near You
With 103 shops across 10 states, there’s a good chance a Whit’s is closer than you think. Most locations cluster in Ohio, with growing footprints in Florida, North Carolina and Tennessee. Searching “Whit’s Frozen Custard near me” on your phone pulls up the closest shop with live hours and directions.
⭐ Whit’s Frozen Custard Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.8/5
Whit’s shops consistently sit in the 4.6 to 4.8 star range on Google, which is elite territory for a dessert chain. What do customers praise? Three things come up again and again: the custard itself (denser and fresher than anything from a freezer aisle), the friendly small-town-shop service, and the Flavor of the Week rotation that keeps visits exciting. The Black Raspberry Chip flavor has a genuine fan club. The rare complaints are the ones you’d expect, occasional melt on hot delivery days and shops that sell out of the weekly flavor early. Fair enough.
