Fazoli’s Secret Menu Guide 2026
Yes, the Fazoli’s secret menu is real, though unofficial. It includes the Pizza Baked Spaghetti (baked spaghetti topped with pepperoni and extra mozzarella), a Cheesy Garlic Bread Sandwich made from their famous breadsticks, a Build-Your-Own Pasta Bowl, and a Fazoli’s Sampler. You order by asking staff politely, since availability varies by location.
I’ll be honest, I had no idea Fazoli’s had anything off-menu until a cashier tipped me off. Fazoli’s doesn’t publish a secret menu anywhere, so everything in this guide comes from employee tips, regulars’ reports, and my own visits. If you want the standard lineup first, browse the full Fazoli’s menu with prices before you go rogue.
🤫 What Is on the Fazoli’s Secret Menu?
Four off-menu creations keep showing up again and again: the Pizza Baked Spaghetti, the Cheesy Garlic Bread Sandwich, the Build-Your-Own Pasta Bowl, and the Fazoli’s Sampler. Here’s the thing, none of these are printed anywhere. They’re just smart customizations of regular menu items, which is exactly why most locations can make them.
Pizza Baked Spaghetti
This is the headliner. They take the regular Baked Spaghetti, pile on pepperoni and extra mozzarella, then bake it so the cheese gets bubbly and the pepperoni crisps up at the edges. Think of it as the best parts of pizza and pasta colliding. If you only try one item from the Fazoli’s secret menu, make it this one.
Cheesy Garlic Bread Sandwich
Regulars figured out that the legendary breadsticks make an unreal sandwich. Ask them to build one with two breadsticks, stuffed with melted mozzarella and provolone, then brushed with garlic butter. It’s cheesy, garlicky, and gloriously messy. Eat it over the tray.
Build-Your-Own Pasta Bowl
Fazoli’s lets you mix and match, so the “secret” here is just knowing to ask. Pick your pasta (penne, spaghetti, or fettuccine), pick your sauce (marinara, alfredo, or meat sauce), then add grilled chicken, meatballs, or extra veggies. It’s the best way to eat exactly what you’re craving without settling.
Fazoli’s Sampler
Can’t decide? The off-menu sampler plates a slice of pizza, a small portion of baked spaghetti, a few ravioli, and of course those breadsticks. It’s basically a greatest-hits tour of the kitchen, and it’s perfect if you’re introducing someone to Fazoli’s for the first time.
Breadstick Hack
Want the breadsticks without all the butter? Ask for them with “no garlic butter” and a side of marinara or alfredo for dipping. Some folks also use leftover breadsticks to build DIY sliders at home.
🗣️ How to Order From the Fazoli’s Secret Menu
The Fazoli’s secret menu only works if you order it the right way. Don’t walk up and say “secret menu.” Instead, describe the customization: “Can you top the baked spaghetti with pepperoni and extra mozzarella before it goes in the oven?” That’s the exact script that works.
A few tips that actually help. Go at off-peak hours, since the kitchen has more time to play ball when it’s not slammed. Be polite and keep it simple, one or two changes per item, not a whole rebuild. And if they say they can’t do it? No big deal. Availability really does vary by location, and some franchisees are stricter about custom orders than others.
One more note: drive-thru and app orders are harder to customize. If you want secret menu items, go inside. The staff can hear you, ask questions, and usually get excited about making something fun.
💲 How Much Do Fazoli’s Secret Menu Items Cost?
Expect regular menu prices plus a small upcharge for the extras. Since these are built from standard items, the base cost is easy to estimate: a regular Baked Spaghetti runs about $9.99, and two signature garlic breadsticks go for roughly $1.99. Toppings like extra cheese, pepperoni, or grilled chicken usually add a dollar or two.
| Secret Item | Base Item | Price (Est.) |
|---|---|---|
| Pizza Baked Spaghetti | Baked spaghetti + pepperoni + extra mozzarella | ~$11–13 |
| Cheesy Garlic Bread Sandwich | 2 breadsticks + mozzarella + provolone | ~$4–6 |
| Build-Your-Own Pasta Bowl | Pasta + sauce + your toppings | ~$10–14 |
| Fazoli’s Sampler | Pizza slice + spaghetti + ravioli + breadsticks | ~$12–15 |
These are estimates, not official prices. Your location’s register might ring them up a little differently, so ask before you order if you’re watching your wallet.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a Fazoli’s secret menu?
Not an official one. But a handful of off-menu customizations, like the Pizza Baked Spaghetti and the Cheesy Garlic Bread Sandwich, are widely reported by customers and employees. Any location can make them since they’re just smart combinations of regular ingredients.
How do I order the Fazoli’s Pizza Baked Spaghetti?
Ask for the baked spaghetti topped with pepperoni and extra mozzarella before it goes into the oven. Ordering inside at a slower time works best, and describing the item beats using the nickname.
Does every Fazoli’s location honor secret menu orders?
No. Availability varies by location and franchise owner. Most will happily customize, but some locations are strict. If one spot says no, another nearby might say yes.
Are Fazoli’s secret menu items more expensive?
Only slightly. Expect the regular item’s price plus a small upcharge for extras like pepperoni or additional cheese, usually a dollar or two.
Prices last verified: October 9, 2026. Secret menu items are unofficial, so prices are estimates based on current menu pricing. Check the official Fazoli’s menu for the latest prices.
