Erbert & Gerbert’s Secret Menu Guide 2026
Here’s the honest truth about the Erbert and Gerberts secret menu: there’s no official one. The chain never published a hidden list. What exists is a set of off-menu hacks regulars swear by: free bread guts for soup, double meat builds, flavor swaps like cranberry wasabi on any sandwich, and retired sandwich recreations the staff still know how to make.
Quick heads-up: if you haven’t browsed the full Erbert & Gerbert’s menu with prices yet, that’s worth a look first, because almost every hack below starts with a regular sandwich and modifies it. Every sandwich comes with one of the chain’s silly little story cards, by the way. The names (Flash, Girf, Comet Candy) come from bedtime stories the founder told his kids back in 1988, and the crew will happily tell you which story your sandwich belongs to if you ask.
What’s on the Erbert and Gerberts Secret Menu?
The Erbert and Gerberts secret menu is fan-made, not corporate. These are the off-menu builds and tricks that actually work in stores, as reported by regulars and reviewers. None of them require a special code word, just knowing what to ask for.
1. The Bread Guts Trick (Free)
This is the most famous Erbert and Gerberts secret menu hack, and it costs nothing. Every sandwich gets its bread hollowed out so the soft inside, called “the guts,” is pulled out and laid on top of your sandwich. Regulars ask the crew to hand over extra guts or bag them up, then use that soft bread for dipping into soup or chili. Pair it with a cup of their chicken wild rice soup and you’ve got a free upgrade to your meal. Nobody charges for this. Just ask.
2. Double Meat Builds
Erbert and Gerberts double meat isn’t on the menu board, but the crew does it all the time. Say “double meat” when ordering any sandwich and they’ll pile on a second portion of turkey, ham, capicola or roast beef for an upcharge. It’s the single best secret menu upgrade if you found a review that said the sandwiches looked light on meat. The Flash, with its capicola, salami and ham, is the fan-favorite double-meat candidate.
3. Flavor Swaps on Any Sandwich
Some of the most loved off-menu sandwiches at E&G are just flavor swaps. The chain’s signature spreads, cranberry wasabi, pesto mayo, Peppadew mustard and chipotle citrus BBQ, are normally locked to specific sandwiches, but you can ask for them on ANYTHING. Cranberry wasabi on a turkey club? The crew will do it. Swap the plain mayo for pesto mayo on the Jacob Bluefinger and the whole sandwich wakes up. This is the deepest customization secret menu bench at the chain.
4. Retired Sandwich Recreations
E&G rotates limited sandwiches (the cheesesteak trio Northern, Cali and Goliath came and went as limited runs, and the hot Meatzilla had its moment too). When they disappear, the builds don’t. If you remember a retired sandwich’s ingredients, ask the crew to rebuild it and they usually can, as long as the ingredients are still in the store. Describe the sandwich, not just the name, because staff turnover is real and a newer employee might not remember a sandwich that ran three summers ago.
5. The Day-Old Bread and Combo Tricks
Two quiet menu hacks: E&G sells day-old bread for next to nothing, perfect for home sandwiches. And the Combo One (sandwich plus chips and a drink) and Combo Two (sandwich plus a cup of soup and a drink) turn any single sandwich into a meal for a couple bucks more than the solo price. Ask for the soup combo specifically, it’s the better value.
How Do You Order Erbert and Gerberts Secret Menu Items?
Ordering the Erbert and Gerberts secret menu is simple: describe the build, don’t use code words. Since there’s no official list, the crew responds to plain requests. Say “Girf with double turkey and cranberry wasabi instead of mayo,” or “Flash, double meat, extra hollowed bread.” Be specific about every change because a vague “make it like the secret menu” gets you a blank stare.
Exact Ordering Scripts That Work
Use these word-for-word at the counter:
- “Can I get the Comet Candy with double roast beef and extra pickles?”
- “Jacob Bluefinger, swap the mayo for pesto mayo, add sun-dried tomato.”
- “Girf, extra hollowed out, and can I get the bread guts on the side for my soup?”
- “Can you make me the Goliath cheesesteak like the limited one? I remember it had peppers, onions, bacon and provolone.”
A fair warning: availability varies. Not every location carries every soup or spread, and a limited-run ingredient that’s been discontinued can’t be resurrected. Order these hacks in-store or by phone so you can confirm on the spot; delivery apps don’t handle customizations well.
How Much Do the Erbert and Gerberts Secret Menu Hacks Cost?
Most Erbert and Gerberts secret menu hacks are cheap. The bread guts trick is free. Flavor swaps between existing spreads usually cost nothing or pocket change. Add-ons have small prices, reviewers have reported banana peppers at about $0.75, sliced pickles around $1.19, cucumbers at a quarter and sun-dried tomato around 50 cents, though these vary by location and may have drifted up.
| Hack | Details | Typical Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Bread guts on the side | Extra hollowed-out bread with any sandwich | Free |
| Flavor swap | Cranberry wasabi, pesto mayo or Peppadew mustard on any sandwich | Free–$1 |
| Double meat | Second portion of any deli meat | $2–$4* |
| Veggie add-ons | Banana peppers, pickles, cucumbers, sun-dried tomato | $0.25–$1.50* |
| Extra cheese | Additional provolone or cheddar slice | $1–$2* |
| Combo Two upgrade | Sandwich plus a cup of soup and a drink | $3–$4* |
*Add-on prices vary by location. Ask at the counter for your store’s exact pricing.
❓ Erbert and Gerberts Secret Menu FAQs
Does Erbert and Gerberts have an official secret menu?
No. The chain has never published an official secret menu. The Erbert and Gerberts secret menu is a collection of fan-discovered hacks: free bread guts, double meat builds, flavor swaps and retired sandwich recreations that the staff will make if you describe them.
What is the bread guts trick at Erbert and Gerberts?
E&G hollows out every sandwich roll and places the soft pulled-out bread, called “the guts,” on top of your sandwich. Ask for the guts on the side or extra, and use it for dipping into soup. It’s free at every location.
Can I put any spread on any sandwich at Erbert and Gerberts?
Yes, in most cases. The crew can swap in cranberry wasabi, pesto mayo, Peppadew mustard or chipotle citrus BBQ on any sandwich that has a spread. Just name the swap when ordering.
Do secret menu hacks cost extra at Erbert and Gerberts?
Some do, some don’t. Bread guts are free, flavor swaps are usually free or under a dollar, and add-ons like extra meat, cheese or vegetables carry small upcharges that vary by location. Always ask for the price at the counter first.
Prices last verified: October 11, 2026. Add-on pricing varies by store, so treat the figures above as ranges. The source of truth is the brand’s official Erbert & Gerbert’s menu page.
