CiCi’s Pizza Secret Menu Guide 2026
CiCi’s secret menu isn’t much of a secret anymore. The chain officially lets buffet guests build a custom 9-inch Personal Pizza with their choice of sauce and up to four toppings at no extra charge. Just ask at the Personal Pizza station or scan the QR code, wait about 10 minutes, and your pager buzzes.
I looked into this because, honestly, I had no idea CiCi’s even had a secret menu until someone at work mentioned it. Turns out the cicis pizza secret menu is one of the more generous deals in fast food, and most regulars don’t even know it exists. Here’s the thing: if you’re buying the buffet anyway, you can get a made-to-order pizza for free. For the full lineup of regular prices, check the full CiCi’s Pizza menu with prices first.
🍕 What Is the CiCi’s Pizza Secret Menu?
Here’s the short version: for decades, CiCi’s quietly let dine-in guests ask for special pizzas. Didn’t see your favorite on the buffet? You could ask the pizza bakers to make it for you. Back in 2018, the company finally made it official and started advertising it as a real program.
The idea is simple. You pay for the buffet, and instead of only eating what’s on the line, you can special-order your own Personal Pizza. The chain calls it the Personal Pizza program, but everyone calls it the cicis pizza secret menu, so that’s what we’ll call it too.
What the secret menu gets you
A 9-inch custom pizza built exactly the way you want it. You pick the crust, the sauce, and up to four toppings from everything the restaurant has on hand. Then they bake it fresh and page you when it’s ready. About 10 minutes, usually.
🛎️ How Do You Order Off the CiCi’s Secret Menu?
The good news: there’s no secret handshake. It’s dead simple.
The exact ordering script
Step 1: Buy the buffet. This part is non-negotiable, the free personal pizza is a buffet-guest perk.
Step 2: Head to the Personal Pizza station (or find the QR code; since 2022, many locations let you order digitally on your phone, which saves flagging down a busy employee).
Step 3: Pick your crust: a traditional 9-inch round or a flatbread.
Step 4: Pick your sauce. There are seven: red pizza sauce, Alfredo, creamy buffalo, honey BBQ, zesty ranch, mac & cheese, or spinach Alfredo.
Step 5: Pick up to four toppings. Meats include pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, beef, chicken, and anchovies. Veggies include green peppers, red onions, black olives, mushrooms, diced tomatoes, jalapeños, and pineapple. Mozzarella goes on automatically.
Step 6: Grab the pager they hand you and hit the buffet line while you wait. It buzzes when your pizza is ready, typically around 10 minutes.
One catch: the offer is one Personal Pizza per person, and it’s dine-in only. You can’t order a free personal pie on a carryout run.
🔥 What Are the Best CiCi’s Secret Menu Hacks?
Knowing how to order is one thing. Ordering well is another. These are the cicis pizza secret menu hacks worth knowing:
Order a specialty pizza as your personal pie
CiCi’s has nine specialty pizzas, think Mac & Cheese, Buffalo Chicken, Spinach Alfredo, and Zesty Ham & Cheddar. If one isn’t on the buffet line, just ask for it on a 9-inch crust as your personal pizza. You get the specialty flavor made fresh.
Swap the sauce base
Most people default to red sauce, but the base is where the magic happens. Buffalo sauce with chicken and bacon plus a jalapeño is a completely different pizza from the same ingredients. Ranch base with chicken and bacon? Also excellent. Ask them, they do it all day.
Go flatbread for extra crisp
Want more crunch? Order your personal pizza on the flatbread base. It bakes up thinner and crispier than the traditional 9-inch crust, and it feels like a totally different pie.
Request a missing buffet pizza
See a gap on the buffet where your favorite used to be? You don’t even have to use the Personal Pizza station. Just ask the pizza bakers if they can make a round of it. They’ve been quietly honoring requests like this for decades, it was the original secret menu.
Ask about Piezilla for parties
This one’s more of a hidden item than a secret: the Piezilla is CiCi’s extra-large 28-inch pizza, built to feed about 15 people. It’s available for pickup and it’s a smart move for game days and birthday parties instead of ordering a stack of regular pizzas. Prices vary by location, so call ahead.
💰 Is the CiCi’s Secret Menu Still Free in 2026?
Yes, with one big condition: you have to buy the buffet. The personal pizza comes at no extra charge for buffet guests. That’s been the deal since 2018 and it hasn’t changed.
A few availability caveats, though. First, most CiCi’s locations are independently owned, so participation can vary; almost all of them do it, but it never hurts to ask. Second, it’s dine-in only, one personal pizza per person. Third, at peak dinner rush the wait might stretch past 10 minutes, so order your personal pie first, then graze the buffet while you wait.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does CiCi’s still have a secret menu in 2026?
Yes. The custom Personal Pizza program is still active at participating CiCi’s locations. Buffet guests can order a made-to-order 9-inch pizza with their choice of sauce and up to four toppings at no extra charge.
Is the CiCi’s secret menu pizza really free?
Yes, with the buffet purchase. You can’t get a free personal pizza without buying the buffet, and it’s limited to one per person for dine-in only. There’s no extra charge beyond what you already paid at the register.
Can I order from the secret menu for carryout?
No. The free custom personal pizza is a dine-in buffet perk only. For carryout, you’re ordering from the regular menu, where you’ll pay the standard price for a customized pizza.
What is Piezilla at CiCi’s?
Piezilla is CiCi’s extra-large 28-inch pizza designed to feed about 15 people. It’s a pickup option that’s popular for parties and game days. Prices and availability vary by location, so call your nearest CiCi’s to order one.
