Joe’s Pizza Menu USA Prices 2026

A single slice will cost you $4.00 for plain cheese in 2026, and trust me, it is the best four dollars you will spend in Manhattan. The joes pizza menu slice lineup is short and perfect. The cheese slice is the star: thin enough to fold, sturdy enough to hold, with that signature Joe’s sauce-to-cheese ratio that has survived fifty years of copycats. Square slices run $4.25, and the specialty slices, vodka, three cheese and the chicken-topped ones, land between $5.00 and $6.00. My pick? The vodka slice. The pink sauce is rich without being heavy, and at $5.00 it feels like a steal for Midtown.

Whole 18-inch pies are the move when you are feeding a group, and they start at $23.00 for the classic extra cheese. That feeds three to four hungry people comfortably, which works out to about six bucks a head. Not bad for Manhattan, right? Most topping pies sit right at $23.00 to $24.00, the three-cheese upgrade is $26.00, and the specialty pies top out at $27.00. The anchovy pie at $24.00 is a salty, briny throwback that old-school New Yorkers still order on purpose.

The specialty pies are where Joe’s shows it can do more than the classic. The three-cheese pie at $26.00 is pure comfort, a bubbling mozzarella-parmesan-ricotta situation that stretches for days. At $27.00, the vodka, BBQ chicken, spicy chicken and chicken tomato pesto pies are the priciest whole pies on the menu, but you get real toppings, not the sad sprinkle some slice shops do. If you are splitting with friends, the $27 vodka pie is my honest recommendation.

Do not sleep on the appetizers. The garlic knots are the cheapest item on the entire menu at $2.50 for five pieces, soft, garlicky, dusted with parmesan, and honestly dangerous. The zeppoli, same price, are little fried dough pillows that hit the spot when you want something sweet with your slice. Mozzarella sticks at $4.00 pull beautifully, and the buffalo wings at $9.00 are a solid shareable. Quick tip: if you are waiting for a pie, order knots first. They come out fast and the table will fight over them.

Yes, though let us be real, most people are not coming here for a salad. Still, the $13.00 grilled chicken salad is genuinely solid: fresh greens, charred chicken, actual crunch. It is the move when someone in your group wants the lighter option while everyone else demolishes slices. Order it with dressing on the side if you are watching calories.

Beyond the pies, the rolls and calzones are the underrated section of the joes pizza menu. The chicken roll at $8.00 is one of the best value items in the whole shop: stuffed with chicken and cheese, baked until the crust crackles. The spicy chicken roll at $10.00 brings real heat. The calzones run $10.00 to $11.00, and the ham and cheese version at $11.00 is basically a meal for two normal humans or one very committed one. These come out of the oven bubbling, so give them a minute. Burned tongues are a rookie mistake.

The hero game is strong here. Cold heros are a flat $13.00 across the board, loaded on fresh bread with real portions of meat. Hot heros run $12.50 to $13.50, and the chicken cutlet hot hero at $13.00 is my pick, crispy cutlet, melted cheese, the works. The peppers and eggs hero at $10.00 is the budget move, an old-school Italian-American classic that still costs less than most Midtown sandwiches.

Yes, there is real pasta on the menu, and it is better than you would expect from a slice shop. Spaghetti with garlic and oil at $13.00 is the cheapest pasta and honestly delicious, simple done right. The baked zitis at $20.00 are bubbling, cheesy beasts that could easily feed two. The penne alla vodka at $16.00 is the sweet spot for value, and the lasagna at $15.00 is a layered, saucy slab of comfort. If you have been living on slices and want a sit-down moment, this is your section.

Let us be honest, nobody walks into Joe’s Pizza counting macros, but here is the quick breakdown anyway. A classic cheese slice is roughly 240 calories, a whole 18-inch cheese pie lands around 2,300, and the garlic knots are about 700 calories for the five-piece order. The grilled chicken salad at about 450 calories is the lightest real meal on the menu. Joe’s does not publish a full nutrition PDF the way big chains do, so treat these as estimates from standard recipes and ask the counter for specifics if you need them.

Joe’s is not a coupon-clipping kind of place, there is no app with points and no weekly BOGO email. But it is already cheap, and a few moves make it cheaper.

• Buy the whole pie for groups. At $23 for an 18-inch pie that feeds 3 to 4, a pie beats buying six slices ($24) every time. Do the math before you order.
• Eat at the counter. Joe’s is a grab-a-slice institution. Ordering slices at the counter skips delivery fees and the delivery price markups entirely.
• Lead with the knots. A $2.50 garlic knot order takes the edge off your hunger while your pie bakes, and it is the cheapest item on the menu.
• Split specialty slices strategically. A $6 specialty slice is a full meal. One specialty slice plus one cheese slice is a feast for about ten bucks.
• Skip delivery when you can. Joe’s delivers through DoorDash, Uber Eats and Slice, but third-party prices run higher than the counter. Pickup is always the cheaper play.

Joe’s keeps late hours, which is part of the legend. The 14th Street location runs 10:00 AM to 3:00 AM Sunday through Wednesday, until 4:00 AM on Thursday, and until 5:00 AM on Friday and Saturday. That 2 AM slice after a night out? This is where it happens. Hours can vary by location, so check the specific shop before a late-night run.

🗺️ Open in Google Maps →