Looking for the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu? This 2026 guide covers every Brooklyn Square Pizza menu price, from the famous $28 upside-down square to the $40 Monday two-pie special.
Brooklyn Square Pizza Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu, then you landed at the right place. Here, you can easily explore the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu with prices along with images and full details. All images and prices are taken from official sources and updated for 2026. This New Jersey pizzeria chain is famous for its upside-down square pizza, that thick, airy Sicilian-style pie with fresh mozzarella hiding under a blanket of sweet homemade tomato sauce. Honestly? One bite and you will get why Dave Portnoy gave it an 8.9.
Look, I have eaten my way through a lot of pizza in my life. Most of it blurs together. But the upside-down square pie at Brooklyn Square Pizza? That one I remember. It is thick without being heavy, airy and fluffy on the inside, with edges so crisp they practically shatter. And then there is the sauce, spooned right over the top of the cheese like some kind of red velvet blanket. It should not work. It completely works.
Brooklyn Square is a family-run New Jersey chain with locations in Jackson, Manalapan, Toms River, Bradley Beach, Shrewsbury and Marlboro, plus a kosher Square Pizza spot in Oakhurst. Owner Peter Grippo built the place on one idea: real Brooklyn-style Sicilian pizza, sesame seed crust and all, served with old-school Italian hospitality. The accolades followed fast. Dave Portnoy’s One Bite gave the square an 8.9. Good Morning America named it the Best Pizzeria in the USA. Jon Stewart randomly walked into the Shrewsbury location one night. Yeah. That kind of place.
Let us talk money, because that is why you are here. How much does Brooklyn Square Pizza cost in 2026? A plain round cheese pie runs $21.00. The famous upside-down square pizza is $28.00. Specialty squares mostly land between $27.00 and $30.00, with the loaded Dream Square at $36.00. Appetizers start at $5.00 for garlic knots. Weekly specials are where the real value hides: on Mondays you get an upside-down square AND a plain round pizza for $40.00, which is genuinely a steal.
🍕 Signature Square Pizza Prices: What Does the Upside-Down Pizza Cost?
As an Amazon Associate, MenuPrice earns from qualifying purchases.
The square pies are the whole reason this place exists. Thick, airy Sicilian crust. Sesame seeds on the bottom. Cheese tucked UNDER the sauce. The signature upside-down square pizza costs $28.00, and the vodka version is $29.00. My pick? The vodka upside-down. Creamy, pink, dangerous.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upside Down Square Pizza | Fresh mozzarella under homemade sauce, pecorino romano, thick airy crust | $28.00 | est. 240/slice |
| Vodka Upside Down Square Pizza | Creamy pink vodka sauce over fresh mozzarella, upside-down style | $29.00 | est. 260/slice |
| The Dream Square Pizza | Loaded signature pie with premium toppings, the works | $36.00 | est. 320/slice |
| Gravesend Square Pizza | Brooklyn-inspired specialty square | $30.00 | est. 280/slice |
| Honeymoon Square Pizza | Sweet-savory specialty combination | $30.00 | est. 280/slice |
| Chicken Grippo Square Pizza | Fried chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, mozzarella, owner Peter Grippo’s namesake | $30.00 | est. 310/slice |
| NJ Square Pizza | Garden State tribute pie | $30.00 | est. 280/slice |
| Johnny Pepe Square Pizza | Classic Italian-American specialty square | $30.00 | est. 290/slice |
| Spinach & Artichoke Square Pizza | Creamy spinach artichoke topping, square style | $30.00 | est. 270/slice |
| Vodka Square Pizza | Classic square with vodka sauce | $27.00 | est. 250/slice |
| Nonna Square Pizza | Grandma-style, garlicky and simple | $27.00 | est. 240/slice |
| Peter’s Special Square Pizza | The owner’s signature combination | $27.00 | est. 280/slice |
🍕 Round Pizza Prices: Classic New York Style Pies
Not in a square mood? The round pies are no afterthought. Hand-stretched, foldable, with that signature sesame seed crust you can spot across the room. A plain round cheese pizza costs $21.00, and specialty rounds run $24.00 to $30.00. These are big pies, built to feed a family.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza | Signature sesame seed crust, homemade pizza sauce | $21.00 | est. 220/slice |
| White Pizza | Ricotta and mozzarella, no red sauce | $24.00 | est. 240/slice |
| Old Fashioned Pizza | Classic Jersey-style pie | $28.00 | est. 250/slice |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | Spicy buffalo chicken, mozzarella | $28.00 | est. 270/slice |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza | Smoky BBQ sauce, grilled chicken | $28.00 | est. 270/slice |
| Chicken Parmigiana Pizza | Breaded chicken, marinara, melted mozzarella | $28.00 | est. 290/slice |
| Chicken Bruschetta Pizza | Fresh tomato bruschetta topping | $28.00 | est. 260/slice |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza | Grilled chicken, Caesar salad on a hot pie | $28.00 | est. 260/slice |
| Susan Grippo Pizza | Family-named specialty pie | $27.00 | est. 270/slice |
| Eggplant & Ricotta Pizza | Roasted eggplant, creamy ricotta | $27.00 | est. 250/slice |
| Popeye Pizza | Ricotta, sauteed spinach, fresh mozzarella | $27.00 | est. 250/slice |
| Marone Pizza | Specialty combination pie | $27.00 | est. 260/slice |
| Spinach, Ricotta & Mushroom Pizza | Earthy, creamy, vegetarian-friendly | $27.00 | est. 250/slice |
| Arugula Salad Pizza | Peppery fresh arugula on top | $26.00 | est. 240/slice |
| Chicken Balsamico Pizza | Balsamic-glazed chicken, rich and tangy | $30.00 | est. 280/slice |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza | Crispy bacon, ranch drizzle, grilled chicken | $30.00 | est. 300/slice |
🧀 Appetizers Prices: What to Order Before the Pie?
Starters here are proper Italian-American comfort food. The cheapest items at Brooklyn Square Pizza live in this section: garlic knots at $5.00 and riceballs at $6.00. Honestly, the zuppa di mussels for $18.00 is a steal for the size of the bowl they bring you.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Knots | Hand-tied, buttery, garlicky | $5.00 | est. 350 |
| Riceball | Classic Italian rice ball, golden fried | $6.00 | est. 300 |
| French Fries | Crispy golden fries | $7.00 | est. 400 |
| Onion Rings | Thick-cut, beer-battered style | $7.00 | est. 450 |
| Garlic Bread | Toasted with garlic butter | $7.00 | est. 400 |
| Garlic Bread with Mozzarella | Cheesy upgrade, worth every penny | $9.00 | est. 550 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | Golden fried, marinara for dunking | $10.00 | est. 650 |
| Rice Ball Special | Loaded rice ball, house special | $10.00 | est. 450 |
| Zucchini Sticks | Lightly fried zucchini | $10.00 | est. 350 |
| Buffalo Wings | Tossed in buffalo sauce | $14.00 | est. 700 |
| Chicken Tenders & Fries | Crispy tenders with a side of fries | $14.00 | est. 850 |
| Fried Ravioli | Cheese-filled, crisped up | $14.00 | est. 700 |
| Baked Clams | Baked with seasoned breadcrumbs | $16.00 | est. 400 |
| Eggplant Rollatini | Rolled eggplant, ricotta, marinara | $16.00 | est. 500 |
| Zuppa di Mussels (Red or White) | Mussels in marinara or white wine garlic sauce | $18.00 | est. 550 |
| Zuppa di Clams (Red or White) | Whole clams, your choice of sauce | $18.00 | est. 550 |
| Fried Calamari | Tender rings, light fry | $18.00 | est. 650 |
| Calamari Marinara | Calamari in homemade marinara sauce | $22.00 | est. 600 |
🥗 Salads & Sides Prices
Yes, people do order salads at a pizzeria. The super Caesar at $20.00 is a full meal, and the house salad at $13.00 is the lightest thing on the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu nutrition-wise. Side orders run $10.00 to $14.00.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| House Salad | Mixed greens, fresh vegetables | $13.00 | est. 250 |
| Caesar Salad | Romaine, parmesan, Caesar dressing | $13.00 | est. 350 |
| Antipasto Salad | Italian meats, cheeses, olives | $17.00 | est. 600 |
| Arugula & Avocado Salad | Peppery arugula, creamy avocado | $18.00 | est. 400 |
| Spring Mix Salad | Tender spring greens | $18.00 | est. 300 |
| Chef Salad | Loaded with meats and cheese | $18.00 | est. 550 |
| Caprese Salad | Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil | $18.00 | est. 400 |
| Greek Salad | Feta, olives, crisp vegetables | $18.00 | est. 450 |
| Grilled Portobello Mushroom Salad | Hearty grilled mushroom cap | $18.00 | est. 350 |
| Spinach Salad | Fresh spinach, toppings | $19.00 | est. 350 |
| Super Caesar Salad | Loaded Caesar, dinner-sized | $20.00 | est. 650 |
Side Orders
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Meatballs | $10.00 |
| Sausage | $10.00 |
| Broccoli | $10.00 |
| Spinach | $10.00 |
| Broccoli Rabe | $14.00 |
🍝 Chicken & Seafood Entrees Prices
Here is the part of the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu most people miss: real Italian dinners. Chicken entrees run $23.00 to $26.00, seafood $23.00 to $29.00, and most are served with your choice of pasta and a side salad. The Wednesday special (two chicken parmigiana dinners for $30.00) is the single best deal on this entire menu.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shrimp Marinara | Shrimp in homemade marinara, pasta & salad included | $23.00 | est. 700 |
| Mussels Marinara (Red or White) | Served with pasta & side salad | $23.00 | est. 650 |
| Shrimp Oreganata | Breadcrumbs, white garlic lemon sauce | $23.00 | est. 700 |
| Shrimp Scampi | Garlic, wine, butter, lemon, paprika | $23.00 | est. 750 |
| Shrimp Parmigiana | Breaded shrimp, tomato sauce, melted mozzarella | $23.00 | est. 800 |
| Shrimp Francese | Egg-battered shrimp, lemon sauce | $25.00 | est. 750 |
| Shrimp Donna | Artichoke hearts, cherry tomatoes, spinach, garlic wine sauce | $25.00 | est. 700 |
| Chicken Ava | Blackened chicken, spinach, cherry tomatoes, Alfredo cream sauce | $26.00 | est. 850 |
| Spicy Seafood Diablo | Clams, mussels, calamari, shrimp in marinara, kicked up | $29.00 | est. 800 |
| Regular Seafood Diablo | Same seafood medley, classic marinara | $29.00 | est. 780 |
🎉 Weekly Specials Prices
Two nights a week, Brooklyn Square Pizza runs specials that slash the bill. Mark your calendar: Mondays and Wednesdays. These are dine-in and pickup deals at participating NJ locations.
| Special | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Monday Special | One upside-down square pizza AND one plain round pizza | $40.00 |
| Wednesday Special | Two chicken parmigiana dinners | $30.00 |
📊 Nutrition Information
Does Brooklyn Square Pizza publish nutrition info? Short answer: not really. There is no official Brooklyn Square Pizza nutrition PDF or calorie chart on the site. It is an independent family chain, so they are not bound by the menu-labeling rules that cover the big national brands.
So what can you do? Use common sense and the estimates in the tables above. A slice of the square pie lands around 240-320 calories depending on toppings. The lightest bets on the menu are the house salad (about 250 calories) and the grilled chicken entrees. The heaviest? Probably the Dream Square slice or the chicken parmigiana pizza slice, both pushing 300+ calories per slice. Ask your server if you are tracking closely, the staff is friendly and the kitchen makes everything fresh, so they can usually tell you what is in a dish.
💰 Deals & Money-Saving Tips
Nobody likes overpaying for pizza. Here is how to keep the Brooklyn Square Pizza menu prices working in your favor:
- Monday special, always. Upside-down square plus a plain round for $40.00. If you are feeding a family, this is the move. No coupon needed, just show up on Monday.
- Wednesday chicken parm night. Two chicken parmigiana dinners for $30.00. That is $15.00 per dinner with pasta and salad. Wild value.
- Order direct. The official site brooklynsquarenj.com links to online ordering. Direct orders skip the third-party delivery markups you see on DoorDash and Caviar.
- Check Slice for promos. Brooklyn Square Pizza Jackson runs occasional Slice promotions (5% off spotted recently). Worth a look before you order.
- Go for the square on a budget night. At $28.00, one square pie feeds 3-4 adults comfortably. Per-person cost? Under $10.00. Try doing that at a sit-down Italian restaurant.
🕐 Brooklyn Square Pizza Opening Hours
What time does Brooklyn Square Pizza open? Most locations open at 11:00 AM daily. Closing times vary a bit by location and day. Typical hours (Toms River location):
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 11:00 AM – 8:45 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 11:00 AM – 9:45 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM – 8:45 PM |
Some spots open at 11:00 AM on Sundays too (Marlboro and Shrewsbury do), and Friday/Saturday closings range from 9:30 PM to 9:45 PM depending on the location. Hours can shift on holidays, so a quick call ahead never hurts.
🏠 About Brooklyn Square Pizza
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a family-owned New Jersey pizzeria chain founded by owner Peter Grippo, built around authentic Brooklyn-style Sicilian square pizza. The original Jackson location set the tone: sesame seed crust, fresh mozzarella tucked under sweet homemade sauce, and a dining room that feels like old-school Brooklyn with red-and-white checkered tablecloths.
Today the chain runs six-plus locations across Central Jersey: Jackson, Manalapan, Toms River, Bradley Beach, Shrewsbury and Marlboro, plus a kosher Square Pizza in Oakhurst. The hype is real and documented: Dave Portnoy scored the square an 8.9 on One Bite, Good Morning America crowned it Best Pizzeria in the USA, and USA Today has spotlighted it among America’s standout pizza spots. Grippo himself is a local legend, known for working the dining room and greeting regulars by name.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular item at Brooklyn Square Pizza?
The upside-down square pizza at $28.00, no contest. It is the signature pie: thick, airy Sicilian crust with fresh mozzarella layered UNDER the homemade tomato sauce and a dusting of pecorino romano. It is the pizza that earned the 8.9 One Bite rating and the Best Pizzeria in the USA title.
What is the cheapest item at Brooklyn Square Pizza?
Garlic knots at $5.00 are the cheapest item on the menu, followed by riceballs at $6.00. For a full meal on a budget, the Monday special (upside-down square plus a plain round for $40.00) feeds a family.
What is an upside-down square pizza?
It is a Sicilian-style square pie built in reverse: the fresh mozzarella goes on the dough first, then the homemade tomato sauce is spooned over the top, finished with pecorino romano. The cheese stays melty under the sauce blanket, and the crust gets extra crisp. Brooklyn Square Pizza is famous for it.
Do Brooklyn Square Pizza prices vary by location?
Yes, slightly. Prices shown here are New Jersey location averages for 2026. Individual locations in Jackson, Manalapan, Toms River, Bradley Beach, Shrewsbury and Marlboro may price a dollar or two differently, and delivery apps add their own markups and fees.
Does Brooklyn Square Pizza deliver?
Yes. You can order delivery through Slice, DoorDash and Caviar, or order direct through brooklynsquarenj.com for pickup or delivery. Ordering direct usually means lower fees than the third-party apps.
What are Brooklyn Square Pizza’s opening hours?
Most locations open at 11:00 AM daily. Monday through Thursday they typically close at 8:45 PM, Friday and Saturday around 9:30-9:45 PM, and Sundays at 8:30-8:45 PM (some locations open at 11:00 AM on Sundays). Check your specific location before heading out.
Why is Brooklyn Square Pizza so famous?
The upside-down square pizza earned an 8.9 rating from Dave Portnoy on Barstool’s One Bite, Good Morning America named it the Best Pizzeria in the USA, and USA Today has featured it among America’s standout pizzerias. Regulars rave about the sesame seed crust, the sweet homemade sauce, and owner Peter Grippo’s hospitality.
Does Brooklyn Square Pizza have deals or coupons?
The standing weekly deals are the Monday special (one upside-down square plus one plain round pizza for $40.00) and the Wednesday special (two chicken parmigiana dinners for $30.00). Watch Slice for occasional percentage-off promotions on the Jackson location.
Does Brooklyn Square Pizza cater or do party orders?
Yes. The big square pies are natural party food, one $28.00 square feeds 3-4 adults, and the Monday $40.00 two-pie special is built for groups. Call your nearest location for larger party orders and catering trays.
Does Brooklyn Square Pizza have nutrition information?
There is no official Brooklyn Square Pizza nutrition PDF or calorie chart. As an independent chain they do not publish full nutrition data. The calorie figures in this article are estimates. The lightest options are the salads (250-450 calories); square pizza slices run roughly 240-320 calories each.
Prices last verified: 2026-10-21. Source of truth: the brand’s official site brooklynsquarenj.com and its official online-ordering menus. Prices are NJ-location averages and may vary by location.
📍 Find Brooklyn Square Pizza Near You
Locations: 265 S New Prospect Rd, Jackson NJ · 73 Wilson Ave, Manalapan NJ · 1898 Hinds Rd, Toms River NJ · 812 Main St, Bradley Beach NJ · 1026 Broad St, Shrewsbury NJ · 460 CR-520, Marlboro NJ · Kosher Square Pizza, Oakhurst NJ.
⭐ Brooklyn Square Pizza Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.5/5 (1,600+ reviews on the flagship Jackson location; Slice rating 4.9/5 from 4,100+ orders)
What customers praise: the light, airy square pies, the sweet homemade sauce, the sesame seed crust, and owner Peter Grippo’s warm hospitality. Common gripes: it is pricier than a corner slice shop (two slices ran one reviewer “a little over $7”), and weekend waits can get long. Fair trade, most say.
