Donatos Pizza Secret Menu Guide 2026
Yes, the Donatos Pizza secret menu is real, and its star is the Pep 200: a large pizza with at least 200 pepperoni slices, double the chain’s famous 100-plus pepperoni count. It’s only sold at the Short North store in Columbus, Ohio. The rest is off-menu customizations you can order anywhere, and I’ll show you how.
If you know Donatos at all, you know the pepperoni thing. A large pepperoni pizza there comes with at least 100 slices, edge to edge, no bald spots. So when I heard there’s a way to double that, I had to look into it. This guide covers every Donatos Pizza secret menu item worth knowing, including the one confirmed off-menu legend, plus the customization hacks regulars use at any location. Want the standard lineup first? Here’s the full Donatos Pizza menu with prices.
What Is on the Donatos Pizza Secret Menu?
The one confirmed legend is the Pep 200, sold only at the Short North location in Columbus, Ohio. Everything else on the Donatos Pizza secret menu is an off-menu customization, from double pepperoni to half-and-half specialty pies, that most locations can make if you ask the right way.
The Pep 200, Donatos’ True Secret Item
Here’s the story. A Columbus food writer watched the Short North Donatos crew prep their famous pepperoni pizza and learned the location quietly sells something called the “Pep 200.” It’s exactly what it sounds like: a large pizza with at least 200 slices of pepperoni on it. Double the standard. Just say the words “Pep 200” and the crew knows what you mean, at that store, anyway.
Fair warning: this is a single-location thing. Don’t walk into a Donatos in Dayton and expect the magic words to work. I’ll explain the workaround in a minute.
The Full Secret Menu Cheat Sheet
| Off-Menu Order | What to Say | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| The Pep 200 | “Can I get the Pep 200?” | Large pizza, 200+ pepperoni. Short North, Columbus, Ohio only. |
| Double Pepperoni | “Double pepperoni on a large, please” | The closest thing to a Pep 200 at any store. Small upcharge. |
| Half-and-Half Specialty | “Half Works, half Serious Meat on one large” | Two signature pizzas on one pie. Great for split opinions. |
| Well-Done Thin Crust | “Cook it well done, extra crispy” | Crunchier edge-to-edge crust. Free to ask. |
| Cauliflower Crust Swap | “Can I get that on cauliflower crust?” | Lighter option, offered at many locations. |
| Hot Honey Drizzle | “Add a hot honey drizzle on top” | Sweet heat on any pizza. Pairs great with pepperoni. |
| Ranch Cups on the Side | “Extra ranch cups, please” | Donatos now makes its ranch fresh with real buttermilk. Get extra for wings and bread. |
How Do You Order Donatos Secret Menu Items?
Call ahead or order in person and name the customization out loud. Most of these don’t exist as buttons in the app or online ordering, so the phone or the counter is your best bet. Honestly, calling takes two minutes and the crew usually loves this stuff.
The Exact Ordering Script
Keep it simple and friendly. Something like: “Hey, quick question, can you do double pepperoni on a large? And cook it well done?” That’s it. Name the size, name the tweak, and you’re done.
Tips That Actually Help
Order in person or by phone. The app and website have limited customization options, and half these hacks just aren’t clickable.
Expect a small upcharge. Extra toppings cost extra, that’s normal. Double pepperoni usually adds a couple of dollars, which is still a steal for what you get.
Be specific about the base pizza. “Double pepperoni on a large Serious Cheese” gets you exactly what you want. “Something secret” gets you a confused look.
Tip well if they hook you up. A crew that builds you a Pep 200-style monster earned it.
Which Off-Menu Customizations Are Worth Trying?
The best bets are double pepperoni, half-and-half specialty pies and the hot honey drizzle, since they use ingredients every store already has on the line. These are the Donatos off-menu hacks regulars swear by.
Double Pepperoni (the Anywhere Pep 200)
This is the big one. Donatos’ whole identity is edge-to-edge pepperoni, at least 100 slices on a large. Asking for double gets you into Pep 200 territory at any location, for a modest upcharge. It’s the closest most of us will ever get to the real thing, and honestly it’s glorious.
Half-and-Half Specialty Pies
Can’t decide between the Works and the Serious Meat? You don’t have to. Ask for half of one specialty and half of another on the same pizza. The kitchen does this all the time, it just isn’t advertised. Works great for couples who never agree on toppings (ask me how I know).
Hot Honey Drizzle
Donatos added a Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza to the lineup, and in August 2026 they rolled out two new permanent chicken pizzas plus fresh house-made buttermilk ranch. The move: ask for a hot honey drizzle on ANY pizza, or grab extra ranch cups to dip your wings and cinnamon bread. Sweet, spicy, creamy. Trust me on this one.
Can You Get the Secret Menu at Every Donatos?
No, and here’s why: Donatos locations are independently owned franchises, so off-menu items depend on the crew and the manager on duty. The Pep 200 is confirmed only at Short North in Columbus. The customizations above, though, use standard ingredients, so most stores can do them.
A few honest caveats. Prices vary by location, so that double-pepperoni upcharge won’t be identical everywhere. The app and website won’t list any of this, so don’t hunt for secret buttons that don’t exist. And if a store says no to something unusual, don’t argue, just enjoy the regular menu, which is already excellent.
Donatos Secret Menu FAQ
Does Donatos Pizza have a secret menu?
Yes. The confirmed secret item is the Pep 200, a large pizza with at least 200 pepperoni slices, sold only at the Short North location in Columbus, Ohio. Beyond that, the Donatos Pizza secret menu is a set of off-menu customizations like double pepperoni, half-and-half specialty pies and hot honey drizzle that most locations can make on request.
What is the Donatos Pep 200?
The Pep 200 is a large Donatos pizza loaded with at least 200 slices of pepperoni, double the chain’s standard 100-plus count. It’s an off-menu item available only at the Short North Donatos in Columbus, Ohio. At other locations, ask for “double pepperoni on a large” to get a close equivalent.
Can I order Donatos secret menu items in the app?
Usually not. Most secret menu customizations aren’t listed as options in the Donatos app or online ordering. Your best bet is to call the store or order at the counter and describe the customization. The crew handles these requests regularly.
Does the Donatos secret menu cost extra?
Sometimes. Simple requests like cooking a pizza well done are free, but extra toppings like double pepperoni carry a small upcharge. Prices vary by location since Donatos stores are independently owned franchises. Expect to pay a couple of extra dollars for loaded-up customizations.
Prices last verified: October 9, 2026. For the most current menu and prices at your location, check the official Donatos menu page as the source of truth.
