Burgatory Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the Burgatory menu, then you landed at the right place. Here you can explore the full Burgatory menu with prices, pictures and honest details, all updated for 2026. Everything below comes from Burgatory’s official menu plus current delivery listings, so you are seeing real numbers, not guesses. Burgatory is Pittsburgh’s beloved build-your-own burger bar. You do not just pick a burger off a board here, you design it on a ticket: the meat blend, the bun, the rub, the cheese, the sauce. And then there are the hand-spun shakes. Oh, the shakes. If burgers are your thing, browse the full Burgers category archive for more menus.
🍔 Smash Burgers Menu Prices
As an Amazon Associate, MenuPrice earns from qualifying purchases.
The smash burgers are Burgatory’s signature line, and honestly they are the reason most first-timers walk in. Every beef smash is $16.50 flat, and the two chicken builds are $14.50, which makes ordering blissfully simple. My pick? The Double Smash. Two griddled patties with those crispy lacy edges, double white American, griddled onions, naughty sauce. It is the burger that made me get what the fuss is about.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Double Smash | Two griddled smash patties, double white American cheese, griddled onions, naughty sauce, dill pickles, bacon, potato bun | $16.50 | 950 |
| Au Poivre Smash | Two griddled smash patties, Swiss cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms, au poivre sauce, garlic mayo, potato bun | $16.50 | 900 |
| Jalapeno Popper Smash | Two griddled smash patties, cheddar jack, griddled onions, queso, pickled jalapenos, bacon, candied jalapeno relish, potato bun | $16.50 | 1050 |
| Chippy Chick | Potato chip crusted ground chicken burger, farmhouse cheddar, bacon, french onion dip, onion straws, honey mustard, pretzel bun | $16.50 | 1000 |
| Hot Honey BBQ Chicken | Local Amish fried chicken dipped in hot honey BBQ, bread and butter pickles, shredded lettuce, mayo, brioche; served with field greens | $14.50 | 850 |
| WTF Chicken | What The Fried chicken, shredded iceberg, dill pickles, honey mustard, brioche; one bite and you will get the name; served with field greens | $14.50 | 800 |
🛠️ Build Your Own Burger: How It Works and What It Costs
This is Burgatory’s whole identity, and the burgatory build your own burger setup is genuinely fun. You get a little ticket and work through five steps. Start with the meat blend ($14 to $16), then pick a bun, a rub, a cheese and a sauce. Most cheeses are a buck, the first sauce is free. Here is the damage at each step.
Step 1: Pick a Burger (the Meat Blend)
| Meat Blend | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hormone Free Beef | The classic, and the best value on the ticket | $14.00 | 750 |
| Natural Ground Chicken | Lighter option, still juicy if you do not overcook it | $14.00 | 600 |
| Chicken Breast | Grilled, lean, the virtuous choice | $14.00 | 550 |
| Vegan Veggie | Cashew-based veggie patty, a real build not an afterthought | $14.00 | 550 |
| Fiddy-Fiddy (Beef & Bacon) | Half beef, half bacon ground right in. Decadent. Worth it. | $14.50 | 850 |
| Impossible Burger | Made entirely of plants, bleeds like the real thing | $15.00 | 650 |
| Natural Bison | Leaner than beef, slightly sweet, my upgrade pick | $16.00 | 700 |
| Dry Aged Wagyu | The splurge. Buttery, funky in the best way | $16.00 | 800 |
Steps 2 to 5: Bun, Rub, Cheese, Sauce
Buns: brioche, whole wheat, pretzel, potato, lettuce wrap, topless or naked (no bun, folks). Gluten-free bun adds $1.50. Rubs: Angel Dust, Texas BBQ, Cracked Peppercorn, Bayou Cajun, Sweet Onion or Wicked Spice, all free, and the peppercorn one is sneaky good. Cheese: most are $1 (white American, sharp provolone, smoked salt gouda, farmhouse cheddar, sharp Swiss, cheddar jack, horseradish cheddar), gorgonzola is $1.50, vegan cheddar is $2. Sauce: first one is free, so go wild.
🥤 Heavenly Shakes Menu Prices
Ask a Pittsburgher what Burgatory is famous for and half of them will say the shakes before they say the burgers. The burgatory milkshakes menu is hand-spun, thick enough to stand a spoon in, and the list is long. Classics run $8, vegan versions $7, and there is always a rotating Special Shake. Feeling brave? They will spike it for you (21+, obviously).
| Shake | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Shakes | Chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, Oreo, Cookie Monster, Campfire S’mores, Cold Brew Brownie, Strawberry Pop-Tart and more | $8.00 | 800-1000 |
| Caramel Pretzel | The cult favorite, salty-sweet and dangerously drinkable | $8.00 | 950 |
| Salted Nutella Crunch | Nutella and Nestle Crunch bars, need we say more | $8.00 | 1000 |
| Oreo Peanut Butter Pie | Oreo. Peanut butter. Pie. Seriously, what else is there to say | $8.00 | 1050 |
| Party Animal | Birthday-cake vibes in a glass | $8.00 | 900 |
| Vegan Shakes | Soy vanilla ice cream, any classic flavor; chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, peanut butter | $7.00 | 700-850 |
| Special Shake (Small) | Rotating monthly special, follow @BurgatoryBar for the current one | $7.00 | 750 |
| Special Shake (Classic) | Rotating monthly special, full size | $9.50 | 1000 |
| Spiked Shakes (21+) | Booze blended right into the shake, not served alongside; ask your server for today’s pour | Varies | 900-1200 |
🍟 Fingers (Appetizers) Menu Prices
Burgatory calls its starters Fingers, and they are not an afterthought. The truffle gorgonzola fries are the move, white truffle oil and Amish gorgonzola over fresh-cut fries. Fair warning: sides are charged separately from burgers here, so budget accordingly or you will be surprised at the register.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Truffle Gorgonzola Fries | Fresh-cut fries tossed with white truffle oil and Amish gorgonzola | $11.50 | 700 |
| Pale Ale Onion Rings | Fat brew-battered rings, house-made spicy ketchup and chipotle horseradish dip | $11.50 | 650 |
| Tempura Fried Mozzarella | Crispy tempura shell, molten middle | $11.50 | 750 |
| Six Napkin Nachos | Tony’s chicken chili, queso, jack and cheddar, pickled jalapenos, grilled corn, lettuce, chipotle lime crema | $14.00 | 1200 |
| Wings (8 pc) | Buffalo, bourbon BBQ or honey habanero, sweet heat done right | $16.00 | 900 |
| Wicked Wings (8 pc) | The spicier wing option for heat seekers | $16.00 | 950 |
🥗 Forks & Spoons: Salads and Chili Menu Prices
Yes, there is salad at a burger bar, and the Sonoma chopped chicken salad is genuinely good, not a sad afterthought. The spoons side of the menu is one glorious chili. Short version: if someone in your group wants something lighter, they are covered.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caesar Salad | Crisp romaine, parmesan, house Caesar | $14.00 | 600 |
| Sonoma Chopped Chicken Salad | Grilled chicken, bacon crumbles, egg, avocado, gorgonzola, red wine vinaigrette | $18.00 | 750 |
| Sierra Steak Salad | Steak-topped chopped salad, the hearty one | $20.50 | 850 |
| Tony’s Chicken Chili | Small-batch chili, grated cheddar, chipotle sour cream, sweet red onions, warm jalapeno cheddar cornbread on the side | $8.00 | 450 |
🍗 Hands: Chicken Sandwiches Menu Prices
The Hands section is Burgatory’s fried chicken sandwich game, and the WTF Chicken Sandwich has a name you will remember. All three are $16, all come on brioche, and honestly the Hot Honey BBQ one gives the smash burgers a run for their money.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| WTF Chicken Sandwich | What The Fried chicken, shredded iceberg, dill pickles, honey mustard, brioche | $16.00 | 900 |
| Hot Honey BBQ Chicken | Fried chicken dipped in hot honey BBQ, pickles, lettuce, mayo, brioche | $16.00 | 950 |
| Wicked-Wich | Spicy fried chicken build with serious attitude | $16.00 | 950 |
🍽️ Sides & Kids Menu Prices
What are the cheapest items at Burgatory? Right here. The sides menu is where the $5 heroes live: smoked pepper baked beans and jalapeno cheddar cornbread with honey butter, both five bucks and both excellent. Kids eat for a flat $9 with four choices.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sea Salt & Herb Fries | Fresh-cut, house seasoned, the everyday fry | $8.00 | 500 |
| Roasted Potato Salad | Roasted potatoes, creamy dressing | $6.50 | 350 |
| Smoked Pepper Baked Beans | Smoked peppers, pork belly, sweet and smoky | $5.00 | 300 |
| Lil’ Simple Green Salad | Lightly dressed field greens | $6.50 | 150 |
| Jalapeno Cheddar Cornbread | Baked fresh, served with honey butter | $5.00 | 280 |
| Deuce Burger Deluxe | Kids: two mini cheeseburgers | $9.00 | 600 |
| Foghorn’s Fried Chicken | Kids: all-natural chicken breast tenders | $9.00 | 500 |
| Grilled Cheese | Kids: gooey American on griddled bread | $9.00 | 550 |
| Mac & Cheese | Kids: creamy white cheddar noodles | $9.00 | 650 |
🥤 Drinks Menu Prices
| Item | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Fountain Sodas | Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, ginger ale, sweet tea, iced tea | $3.25 – $4.00 |
| Natrona Bottled Sodas | Pittsburgh’s own Natrona root beer and ginger beer | $3.75 – $5.00 |
| Berry Lemonade | House-made, tart and refreshing | $5.00 |
| Arnold Palmer | Half iced tea, half lemonade | $5.00 |
| Apple Juice Box | For the little ones | $1.95 – $2.50 |
📊 Burgatory Nutrition Information
How many calories are in a Burgatory burger? Here is the honest answer: Burgatory has around a dozen locations, which means it is not required to post full nutrition panels, and it does not publish an official nutrition PDF. The calorie figures in the tables above are our estimates based on typical portions and comparable items, so treat them as a rough guide, not gospel.
That said, some patterns are clear. A Double Smash lands around 950 calories, the hand-spun shakes run 800 to 1,000 (they are dessert, nobody is pretending otherwise), and the wings and nachos are shareable for a reason. Eating lighter? The grilled chicken breast build-your-own starts around 550 calories, the Lil’ Simple Green Salad is about 150, and you can always go topless or naked on the bun to cut a couple hundred calories. The vegan veggie patty at around 550 is one of the lightest full burgers on the ticket.
💰 Burgatory Deals & Money-Saving Tips
Looking for burgatory deals and coupons? There is no points-based rewards app as of 2026, so the savings game here is about knowing the monthly specials and ordering smart. Here is how the regulars do it.
1. Watch the Burger of the Month. Every month Burgatory drops a limited burger (about $18 in-store) and a Special Shake ($7 small, $9.50 classic). Follow @BurgatoryBar on social, that is literally where they announce it.
2. Build your own from $14. The hormone-free beef base at $14 with the free first sauce is the best value burger in the building. Skip the wagyu upgrade unless you are celebrating.
3. Share the Fingers. The $14 Six Napkin Nachos and $16 wings are built for the table. Split one between two people as a starter and nobody leaves hungry.
4. Check delivery promos. Burgatory is on DoorDash and Uber Eats, and both run new-user and DashPass promos that can beat in-store totals on a big order.
5. Kids eat for $9 flat. Four choices, all nine bucks, no kids-menu sticker shock.
🕐 Burgatory Opening Hours
Most Burgatory locations keep the same rhythm: open at 11:00 AM every day, closing at 9:00 PM Sunday through Thursday and 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Holiday hours vary, so check the location page before a holiday run.
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM (some locations 10:00 PM) |
🏠 About Burgatory
Burgatory is a Pittsburgh-born burger bar that grew from a single local spot into roughly a dozen locations across Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia, all run out of its Pittsburgh headquarters. The concept is simple and brilliant: a five-step ticket where you choose the meat blend, bun, rub, cheese and sauce, plus a full bar pouring local brews and blending spiked shakes. It is part burger joint, part neighborhood bar, and Pittsburgh treats it like an institution.
❓ Burgatory Menu FAQs
What is the most popular item on the Burgatory menu?
The Double Smash at $16.50 is the signature order: two griddled smash patties with crispy edges, double white American cheese, griddled onions, naughty sauce, pickles and bacon. The build-your-own burger (from $14) and the Caramel Pretzel shake ($8) are close behind.
How much does a burger cost at Burgatory in 2026?
Build-your-own burgers start at $14 for hormone-free beef and run to $16 for bison or dry-aged wagyu. Signature smash burgers are $16.50, chicken sandwiches are $14.50 to $16, and the rotating Burger of the Month is about $18 in-store.
What is the cheapest thing you can order at Burgatory?
The cheapest full menu items are the $5 sides: smoked pepper baked beans and jalapeno cheddar cornbread with honey butter. The cheapest drink is an apple juice box at $1.95 to $2.50, and fountain sodas start at $3.25.
How does the build-your-own burger ticket work?
You fill out a five-step ticket: 1) pick a meat blend ($14 to $16), 2) pick a bun (brioche, pretzel, potato, lettuce wrap and more; gluten-free adds $1.50), 3) pick a free rub, 4) pick a cheese (most $1), 5) pick a sauce (first one free). The kitchen builds exactly what you ticked.
Does Burgatory deliver?
Yes. Burgatory offers delivery and pickup through DoorDash and Uber Eats, and many locations are DashPass eligible. Expect delivery menu prices to run a couple of dollars higher per item than in-store prices.
Does Burgatory have vegan and vegetarian options?
Yes, and they are real options, not afterthoughts. The Vegan Veggie patty is $14 and the Impossible Burger is $15 on the build-your-own ticket, vegan shakes are $7, and there is vegan cheddar for $2. Salads and sides round out the meat-free choices.
Can you get spiked milkshakes at Burgatory?
Yes, and it is one of their claims to fame. The alcohol is blended right into the hand-spun shake rather than served alongside. You must be 21+, and flavors and pricing change, so ask your server what they are pouring.
Does Burgatory have coupons, deals or a rewards app?
There is no points-based rewards app as of 2026. The best deals are the monthly Burger of the Month (about $18), the rotating Special Shake ($7 small / $9.50 classic) announced on @BurgatoryBar, and delivery app promos on DoorDash and Uber Eats.
Is there a Burgatory near me?
Burgatory has roughly a dozen locations across Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia, concentrated around Pittsburgh. Use the map below or the official store locator on burgatorybar.com to find the closest one.
What are Burgatory’s opening hours?
Most locations open at 11:00 AM daily, closing 9:00 PM Sunday through Thursday and 10:00 PM Friday and Saturday. Some locations stay open until 10:00 PM on Sundays. Hours can vary by location and on holidays.
Prices last verified: October 21, 2026. Source of truth: the official Burgatory menu at burgatorybar.com.
📍 Find Burgatory Near You
⭐ Burgatory Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.5/5 (from around 4,300 Google reviews)
Customers consistently praise the hand-spun shakes (spiked versions especially), the freedom of the build-your-own ticket, and burger quality well above typical fast-casual. Common gripes: sides sold separately push the total higher than expected, and weekend waits can stretch at the busiest Pittsburgh spots. Overall, it is one of the best-reviewed burger bars in the city.
🔗 Related Menus
That is the full Burgatory menu with 2026 prices, from the $14 build-your-own ticket to the $16.50 smash burgers and those legendary $8 hand-spun shakes. If you are anywhere near Pittsburgh, the Double Smash and a Caramel Pretzel shake is the order. You will not regret it.
