Andy’s Frozen Custard Secret Menu Guide 2026
Andy’s Frozen Custard does not print an official secret menu, but that has never stopped fans from inventing one. The real andys frozen custard secret menu is a loose collection of off-menu concretes like the German chocolate cake concrete, the Texas 2-Step and the Snow Monster, plus the famous custom concrete option that unlocks over 54,000 flavor combinations. Here is what to order and exactly how to ask for it.
I’ll be honest, the first time I heard someone order a “German chocolate cake” at an Andy’s drive-thru, I thought they’d lost their mind. Then I tried it. If you are new to Andy’s, start with the full Andy’s Frozen Custard menu with prices so you know the regular lineup, then come back here for the good stuff.
Does Andy’s Frozen Custard actually have a secret menu?
No, there is no printed secret menu hanging behind the counter. But Andy’s runs on a toppings menu that is practically built for secret ordering: you can blend nearly any topping into vanilla or chocolate custard, and staff will happily make fan-named creations if you describe them. That is the whole trick. The “secret” is knowing the names and the recipes.
Some of these combos, like the Snow Monster, started as fan requests and eventually earned a spot on the official menu. Others, like the German chocolate cake concrete that reviewers keep raving about, still live purely in fan territory. Either way, every store makes custard fresh every hour, so a secret order tastes just as good as anything on the board.
What are the best Andy’s secret menu items to order?
These are the ones worth your money. Every item below can be ordered at any Andy’s, either by name (older, well-known combos) or with a one-line recipe for the cashier.
| Secret Item | What It Is | Exact Order Script | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| German Chocolate Cake | Vanilla custard blended with fudge brownie pieces, roasted pecans and crème caramel, a nod to the classic cake | “Vanilla concrete with brownie pieces, roasted pecans and crème caramel, like a German chocolate cake” | ~$6.40 |
| Texas 2-Step | Vanilla custard blended with strawberries, then filled with a hot fudge center | “Texas 2-Step, strawberries with a hot fudge center” | ~$6.20 |
| Snow Monster | Strawberries and melted chocolate chip blended through the custard | “Snow Monster” (now on most menus) | ~$4.74–$6.00 |
| Straw-Ana | The Original Straw-Ana, strawberry and banana over custard | “Straw-Ana sundae” | ~$5.70–$6.50 |
| James Brownie Funky Jackhammer | Custard blended with creamy peanut butter and brownies, filled with hot fudge | “James Brownie Funky Jackhammer” | ~$7.54 |
| Rico Suave | Roasted pecans and Oreos blended in, with a hot fudge filled center | “Rico Suave” | ~$5.50–$6.80 |
| Cherry Bash | Chocolate syrup, maraschino cherries, Heath Bar and almonds | “Cherry Bash concrete, chocolate syrup, cherries, Heath and almonds” | ~$6.20 |
| Choc-O-Rocko | Roasted almonds and marshmallow crème, simple and dangerously smooth | “Choc-O-Rocko” | ~$6.60 |
| BootDaddy | Oreo, crème caramel and hot fudge blended through vanilla or chocolate custard | “BootDaddy” | ~$4.99–$6.20 |
| Build Your Own | Any 2–3 toppings blended into vanilla or chocolate custard, 54,000+ combos possible | “Custom concrete, [topping] with [topping]” | ~$4.60–$6.40 |
My honest rankings
I would rank the German chocolate cake concrete first, no contest. The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer is the heavyweight pick if you want maximum richness, and the Snow Monster is the safe crowd-pleaser. The Cherry Bash is underrated, it sounds like a lot but the cherries and Heath Bar play really well together. Skip nothing, honestly, but start with the German chocolate cake.
How do you order the Andy’s frozen custard secret menu without sounding lost?
The andys frozen custard secret menu works on a simple rule: describe it, don’t just name it. Most cashiers know the classics (Snow Monster, Texas 2-Step, James Brownie Funky Jackhammer) by name. For the fan-made ones, give the topping list from the table above. Say it confidently at the drive-thru or walk-up window and you will get exactly what you want.
Ordering tips that actually help
- Pick your base first: vanilla custard is the default and pairs with everything. Chocolate custard works with peanut butter, caramel and Oreo combos.
- Say “concrete” for blended items and “Jackhammer” for a filled center: a Jackhammer is any one-topping concrete with a surprise center of another topping. That trick alone doubles your secret options.
- Ask about seasonal items: stores rotate limited treats like pumpkin pie concrete and apple pie concrete in the fall, and key lime pie concrete in spring. These come and go, so ask what is in the case.
- Drive-thru is fine: the crew does custom orders all day, you are not annoying anyone. Keep the order to one or two customs per visit so the line keeps moving.
How much do Andy’s secret menu items cost?
Secret items cost about the same as regular menu items, since most are just topping combinations the staff blends for you. Expect roughly $4.74 to $6.60 for custom concretes and $6.60 to $7.54 for filled Jackhammers like the James Brownie Funky. A build-your-own concrete is usually the cheapest secret option.
Prices vary by location and franchise, so what you pay in Springfield, Missouri might differ from Dallas or Tampa. Nothing here carries a secret surcharge, though, which is part of the fun.
What seasonal secret treats should I watch for?
Andy’s seasonal rotation is basically a second, temporary secret menu. The pumpkin pie concrete in fall, made with slices of pie baked fresh in-store, is the one fans plan around. Apple pie concrete shows up in autumn too, key lime pie concrete lands in spring and summer, and limited runs like Biscoff cookie butter have sold out fast. If it is not on the board, ask. Seasonal concretes are also available as pints and quarts to take home, which is perfect for sharing.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does Andy’s Frozen Custard have an official secret menu?
No, Andy’s does not publish an official secret menu. The secret menu is made up of fan-named combinations and the custom concrete option, which most employees will make for you if you describe the toppings.
What is the German chocolate cake concrete at Andy’s?
It is a fan-created concrete: vanilla frozen custard blended with fudge brownie pieces, roasted pecans and crème caramel, mimicking the flavors of German chocolate cake. Order it with the script in the table above.
Can you order secret menu items at the drive-thru?
Yes. Custom concretes and Jackhammers are everyday requests at Andy’s, so the drive-thru crew handles them constantly. Ordering by topping list keeps things quick.
Are secret menu items more expensive?
No, they price the same as regular concretes and Jackhammers. Expect around $4.74 to $7.54 depending on the item and your location, with no secret markup.
