16 Handles Menu USA Prices 2026

Walk into any 16 Handles shop and the first thing that hits you is the wall of flavor handles. Sixteen of them, gleaming, each one promising something better than the last. That’s the whole point of the place. Nobody hands you a pre-made cup here. You grab a cup, you pull the handles yourself, and you build the exact frozen yogurt creation you’re craving. Then comes the fun part and, honestly, the dangerous part: the toppings bar. Fifty-plus toppings staring you down, from fresh strawberries to crushed Oreos to gummy bears you’ll tell yourself are for a kid. They are not. They’re for you.

The 16 Handles menu is built around one simple idea: self-serve frozen yogurt priced your way. Most shops sell set cup sizes (Mini through Large), while some still do the classic pay-by-weight swirl. Either way you end up with artisan soft-serve made from high-quality, non-GMO dairy, plus ice creams, sorbets, milkshakes, smoothies, and even edible cookie dough. Below you’ll find the full 16 Handles menu with prices for 2026, the flavors worth trying, how the nutrition shakes out, the deals that actually save money, and everything else you need before your next visit.

What Are 16 Handles Menu Prices?

Here’s the direct answer: at most 16 Handles locations in 2026, a Mini cup (6 oz) costs $7.95, a Small (9 oz) costs $9.95, a Medium (13 oz) costs $13.95, and a Large (16 oz) costs $16.95. Some shops still price by weight instead, typically around $0.79 to $0.89 per ounce. Prices vary by location, so always check your local shop’s board.

The self-serve model is the star of the show and honestly the best value in the building, because you control the portions. If you’re the type who piles on three pounds of toppings, you’ll pay for it. If you’re disciplined (I’m not), a Small cup of froyo with a reasonable amount of fresh fruit is a genuinely reasonable dessert. Here’s how the set cup pricing breaks down:

My pick? The Small. It’s the sweet spot. A 9 oz cup holds plenty of froyo plus a solid layer of toppings without the price creeping into “I could have bought lunch” territory. And here’s a veteran move: swirl two flavors together in one cup. Half Made with Nutella, half Birthday Cake. Trust me on this one.

Which Flavors Can You Get at 16 Handles?

The direct answer: 16 Handles rotates 16 flavors at a time, mixing permanent signatures (Made with Nutella, Chocolicious, Tahitian Vanilla Bean, Birthday Cake, Original Tart) with seasonal and limited-edition runs like Duff’s Chocolate Chip Cake and Welch’s Mighty Concord Grape. Every flavor’s nutrition is posted right at the machine, which is a nice touch.

This is where 16 Handles genuinely shines. The flavor lineup changes with the seasons, so there’s always something new to try, but the core signatures never leave. Here’s the permanent-ish lineup you’ll find at most shops:

Then there are the limited runs, and this is why regulars keep coming back. 16 Handles has done collabs like Duff’s Chocolate Chip Cake with Food Network star Duff Goldman, Welch’s Mighty Concord Grape, Cookie Butter, Stok Cold Brew Gelato, Pistachio Passion Gelato, Mint Chocolate Chip, Fudge Brownie, and Oh My Pumpkin Pie in the fall. They’ve also partnered with Oatly on oatmilk flavors. If you see a flavor of the month board, take it seriously. It might not be there next visit.

And the toppings? Over 50 of them. Fresh fruit (strawberries, blueberries, kiwi, mango), crushed cookies, brownies, mochi, boba pearls, gummy candy, nuts, granola, and a whole lineup of sauces and syrups. Pro tip from someone who’s made the mistake: weigh your cup mentally as you go. Toppings are where a $9.95 cup becomes a $16 cup.

Does 16 Handles Have Vegan and Dairy-Free Options?

Yes, and they’re legitimately good. 16 Handles always keeps several vegan and dairy-free soft-serve options in the rotation, including fruit sorbettos, a vegan chocolate hazelnut truffle, and oatmilk-based froyo at many shops. If dairy is a no-go for you, you can absolutely build a great cup here.

One caution: the topping bar is shared, so if you have a serious dairy or nut allergy, the froyo machines are clearly labeled but cross-contact is possible. The staff can answer allergen questions, and each shop labels which toppings are kosher, which is a thoughtful detail you don’t see everywhere.

How Much Are 16 Handles Specialties and Shakes?

Direct answer: beyond the self-serve cups, 16 Handles sells milkshakes for $10.95, edible DŌ cookie dough cups for $12.50, smoothies for $6.95, and frozen yogurt cakes starting around $29.95. Take-home pints run about $9.95.

The specialties are where the menu gets interesting for anyone who doesn’t want the DIY route. The Cookies and Cream Milkshake, made with crushed Oreos, is thick and properly indulgent. And the Brookie Dough cup is a sleeper hit: signature chocolate chip and brownie batter swirled together, made by DŌ (Cookie Dough Confections), the edible-cookie-dough folks. If you’re a cookie dough person, this one is worth the trip on its own.

What Smoothies Does 16 Handles Serve?

Direct answer: all six 16 Handles smoothies cost $6.95 each: BFF, Acai Elixir, BRR Berry, Surf’s Up, Oh Kale Yeah, and Tropic Thunder.

Honestly, the smoothies fly under the radar here, which is a shame because they’re solid. They’re the lighter play when you want something fruity without the full froyo commitment. Here’s the lineup:

My honest take: the BFF and Acai Elixir are the two I’d order again. Oh Kale Yeah is the “I’m being good today” choice, and it’s genuinely drinkable, which is more than I can say for most kale smoothies.

How Many Calories Are in 16 Handles Frozen Yogurt?

Direct answer: most 16 Handles frozen yogurt flavors run 90 to 150 calories per half-cup serving before toppings. Every flavor’s nutrition facts are posted at the machine, so you can check before you swirl.

Frozen yogurt has a health-halo reputation, and 16 Handles leans into it with better-for-you options, but let’s be real: a Large cup buried under brownie chunks and hot fudge is a dessert, not a wellness product. That said, the transparency is excellent. Each machine displays full nutrition info, so you can see exactly what you’re getting. Here’s the general landscape:

Toppings are where the calorie math gets wild, and the fruit-vs-candy decision at the bar genuinely matters. A cup of tart froyo with fresh strawberries and blueberries can stay under 300 calories. The same cup with crushed Oreos, brownie bites, and hot fudge can sail past 800 without breaking a sweat. No judgment either way, just know what you’re signing up for.

Looking for a 16 Handles nutrition PDF or detailed allergen chart? The brand posts nutrition info in-store at every flavor machine, and many shops will share printed nutrition details on request. Your best bet for exact figures on a specific flavor is to ask your local shop, since the rotating lineup changes what’s on the machines.

How Can You Save Money at 16 Handles?

Direct answer: the best 16 Handles deals in 2026 are the free 16 Handles app (earn points on every purchase plus a $5 birthday reward), DoorDash’s $3 off $25+ offer at many locations, and Groupon+ 5% cashback at participating shops.

Froyo isn’t the cheapest habit, so the savings actually matter here. The 16 Handles Rewards app is the one move everyone should make. You earn points on every purchase, in-store and on pickup or delivery orders, and you get a $5 reward on your birthday. Points expire 365 days after you earn them, so there’s no real pressure to rush back. Redeemed rewards typically last 90 days.

• 16 Handles app: earn points on every order, $5 birthday reward, exclusive member deals and holiday specials. Scan your QR code at checkout in-store, or order pickup/delivery right in the app.
• DoorDash $3 off $25+: many 16 Handles locations run this promo on DoorDash, and some stack a 20% off $25+ coupon. Check before you order delivery.
• Groupon+ 5% cashback: link your card through Groupon+ at participating shops and get 5% back as statement credit. Small, but it adds up if you’re a regular.
• The Mini cup strategy: a 6 oz Mini at $7.95 satisfies a real craving. It’s the cheapest froyo on the menu and honestly enough for most people.
• Watch for National Soft Serve Day: 16 Handles has given rewards members free 4 oz soft-serve on National Soft Serve Day. Follow the app for holiday promos.

When Is 16 Handles Open?

Direct answer: most 16 Handles shops open around noon and close at 10 or 11 PM. NYC locations stay open until midnight Thursday through Saturday. Hours vary by shop, so check your local store before heading out.

Typical hours look like this, but franchises set their own schedules, so a quick Google check on your specific 16 Handles saves you a sad locked-door moment:

NYC shops (Chelsea, UES, Murray Hill) commonly run noon to midnight on Thursday through Saturday, which is great news for late-night dessert emergencies. Some suburban shops open earlier on weekends. Holiday hours vary, so check the shop’s Google listing on holidays.

About 16 Handles

16 Handles was founded in 2008 in New York City’s East Village, and it was the first self-serve frozen yogurt shop in the city. The concept was simple and it stuck: artisan frozen yogurt in rotating flavors, a massive toppings bar, and you build your own cup. The name comes from the original 16 flavor handles, and the brand has kept that number as its identity even as the menu expanded into ice creams, sorbets, shakes, smoothies, edible cookie dough, and froyo cakes.

Headquartered in New York, NY, 16 Handles now runs shops across New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Texas, Arizona, South Carolina, and beyond, most of them franchised. Every flavor starts with high-quality, non-GMO dairy sourced from local farms, and shops carry dairy-free, no-sugar-added, and kosher-certified options. The brand is also known for its flavor collabs (Duff Goldman, Welch’s, Oatly, DŌ cookie dough) that keep the menu feeling fresh year after year.

16 Handles Menu FAQs

Prices last verified: October 22, 2026. Source: 16 Handles official website.

Prices shown are national averages and can vary by location. 16 Handles shops are individually franchised, so your local shop’s menu and pricing may differ. Menu items and availability change with the seasons.

Find 16 Handles Near You

16 Handles Google Reviews

Related Menus

If you’ve never been, the 16 Handles menu is worth exploring in person at least once. Grab a Small cup, swirl two flavors, and go easy on the toppings bar on your first visit. Once you know your favorites, go wild.