PJ’s Coffee Secret Menu Guide 2026
Yes, the PJ’s Coffee secret menu is real, and it is packed with off-menu drinks you won’t find on the board. From the spicy Café de Olla cold crème to the candy-sweet Snickers cold brew, here are 10 secret PJ’s Coffee drinks, the exact words to order each one, and what they cost.
I’ll be honest, I walked past PJ’s Coffee for years thinking it was just another regional chain. Then a friend ordered something called a Café de Olla cold crème, a drink I’d never seen on any menu board, and I fell down the rabbit hole. Turns out this New Orleans-born chain has one of the friendliest secret menus in coffee, built by adventurous baristas and regulars who started mixing the chain’s syrups, cold brews and teas into creations of their own. If you want the regular lineup first, browse the PJ’s Coffee menu with prices, then come back and order like an insider.
Does PJ’s Coffee Have a Secret Menu?
Yes, it does. PJ’s Coffee has acknowledged its secret menu on its social media pages, and the lineup comes from adventurous baristas and creative regulars who remix the chain’s syrups, cold brews and teas into drinks that never made the official board. Here’s the thing, though: not every barista knows every recipe, and the secret menu varies by location depending on which ingredients are in stock. That is exactly why this guide gives you the ingredients for each drink, so you can order with confidence anywhere.
What Are the Best PJ’s Coffee Secret Menu Drinks?
The PJ’s Coffee secret menu drinks below are the ones real customers keep ordering, ranked by how often they come up in reviews and coffee forums. Each one includes the exact ordering script that works even if your barista has never heard the name.
1. Café de Olla Cold Crème
The most popular secret menu drink at PJ’s, hands down. It has been a fan favorite since it joined the secret lineup around 2020: cold brew coffee blended with Mexican spices, clove and cinnamon, finished with a swirl of cold crème whipped cream. Spicy, creamy and completely different from anything on the board.
Say this: “Can I get a cold brew with cinnamon and a little clove, topped with cold crème whipped cream?”
2. Snickers Cold Brew
Candy bar in a cup. PJ’s cold brew gets hit with caramel, chocolate and peanut butter flavors for a sweet, nutty drink that tastes like the candy aisle met a coffee shop. Dangerously easy to drink.
Say this: “Can I get a cold brew with caramel, chocolate and peanut butter syrups?”
3. King Cake Latte
Inspired by the Mardi Gras dessert, this one blends espresso and milk with cinnamon and vanilla flavors that mimic the classic king cake, complete with that cream-cheese-icing sweetness. It shows up as a seasonal special around Carnival, but regulars order it off-menu the rest of the year (see below).
Say this: “Can I get a latte with cinnamon and vanilla, extra whipped cream?”
4. Bananas Foster Iced Latte
Espresso, milk and a rich bananas foster syrup, all the caramelized brown-sugar flavor of the famous New Orleans dessert without the flambé. Sweet, creamy and very PJ’s.
Say this: “Can I get an iced latte with bananas foster syrup?”
5. Chocolate-Covered Cherry Latte
Chocolate and cherry syrups in a hot or iced latte, a dessert-style drink that tastes like the candy, only warmer and way better with real espresso.
Say this: “Can I get a latte with chocolate and cherry syrups, whipped cream on top?”
6. Almond Joy Iced Coffee
Say this: “Iced coffee with coconut, chocolate and almond syrups.” Tastes like the candy bar, obviously.
7. S’mores Mocha
Say this: “An iced mocha with toasted marshmallow syrup and whipped cream.” Campfire vibes, no campfire required.
8. Caramel Apple Cider
Say this: “A steamed apple cider with caramel syrup.” No caffeine at all, so the kids can order one too.
9. Berries and Cream Tea
Say this: “An iced berries tea with strawberry puree and lavender syrup, topped with coconut milk.” Fruity, floral and creamy, a great non-coffee pick.
10. Iced Matcha Oat Milk Latte
Say this: “An iced matcha oat milk latte with honey jasmine syrup.” Earthy, lightly sweet and dairy-free.
How Do You Order a Secret Menu Drink at PJ’s Coffee?
Order by ingredients, never by name. That is the single most important rule of the PJ’s Coffee secret menu. Walk up and say “Snickers cold brew” and you might get a blank stare, but say “a cold brew with caramel, chocolate and peanut butter syrups” and any barista can make it in seconds. A few more tips I picked up: check that your location carries the syrups before getting your heart set on something exotic, keep it to two or three flavor add-ins so the drink doesn’t turn muddy, and be patient during the morning rush. Secret menu drinks take a touch longer to build, and a little kindness goes a long way.
How Much Do Secret Menu Drinks Cost at PJ’s Coffee?
Expect roughly $5.50 to $8.50 depending on the base drink and how many extras you add. PJ’s charges around $1.12 per extra syrup pump and $1.12 for whipped cream, so a secret menu drink usually runs $1 to $2 more than its base. The good news: alternative milks (oat, almond, coconut) are now free at PJ’s, so the matcha oat milk latte costs the same as the regular version.
| Base Drink | Typical Price | With Secret-Menu Add-ins |
|---|---|---|
| Cold Brew | ~$4.74 | Secret builds like Snickers or Café de Olla land around $6.50-$7.50 |
| Iced Latte | ~$4.65 | Flavored secret lattes run about $6.00-$7.00 |
| Vanilla Velvet Ice | ~$7.62 | Already premium; add-ins push it to $8.00-$8.50 |
| Caramel Granita | ~$7.25 | Extra syrups add ~$1 each on top |
| Iced Matcha Latte | ~$6.50 | Honey jasmine or other syrups ~$1 more |
Can You Get the King Cake Latte Outside Mardi Gras Season?
Sometimes, yes. The King Cake latte is a seasonal star during Carnival season (roughly January through February), when PJ’s goes all-in on the purple whipped cream and Mardi Gras flavors. The rest of the year it depends on whether your location still has the cinnamon-vanilla syrups in stock. It never hurts to ask, the worst they can say is no, and plenty of locations keep the syrups around because regulars keep requesting them. If they are out, the Bananas Foster iced latte scratches a similar sweet-spice itch.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular secret menu drink at PJ’s Coffee?
The Café de Olla cold crème, a cold brew with Mexican spices, clove and cinnamon topped with cold crème whipped cream. It has been the fan favorite since it joined the secret menu around 2020.
What if my barista doesn’t know the secret menu drink I want?
Order by ingredients, not by name. Every secret menu drink is built from regular syrups and bases, so listing the base drink plus each add-in (“a cold brew with caramel, chocolate and peanut butter syrups”) works at any location.
Do these secret menu drinks cost more?
Usually $1 to $2 more than the base drink, since extra syrup pumps run about $1.12 each. Alternative milks are free, so dairy-free secret drinks don’t cost extra.
Is the PJ’s Coffee secret menu the same at every location?
No. The secret menu varies by location and ingredient availability, since franchise stores stock slightly different syrups. The drinks in this guide use common ingredients most locations carry, but always confirm with your barista.
Prices last verified: October 10, 2026. Source of truth: the official PJ’s Coffee menu at pjscoffee.com.
