Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the picklemans cafe menu, then you landed at the right place. Here, you can easily explore the picklemans cafe menu with prices along with images and full details. All images and prices are taken from official sources and updated for 2026. Pickleman’s is the Midwest’s answer to boring lunch, a fast-casual cafe built around seventeen numbered toasted sandwiches, thin-crust tavern pizzas, loaded mac & cheese bowls, and soups that actually taste homemade. The chain started in Columbia, Missouri in 2005 and has quietly grown past 35 locations across seven states.
🥪 What Toasted Sandwiches Does Pickleman’s Serve?
As an Amazon Associate, MenuPrice earns from qualifying purchases.
All seventeen numbered sandwiches are toasted on freshly baked white or wheat bread, and every one can be turned into a romaine lettuce wrap. Prices below are the 2026 national average, your local franchise owner may price a little differently.
Honestly, the numbering system is the best thing about ordering here. You don’t have to remember a long Italian name at the counter, you just say “#11” and they know. It makes the line move fast, which matters at lunch when half of Columbia, Missouri seems to be in it.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 Turkey | Honey mesquite smoked turkey breast, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $9.88 | 640 |
| #2 Ham | Smoked ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $9.33 | – |
| #3 Veggie | Extra provolone, cucumber, avocado, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $8.23 | – |
| #4 Chicken Salad | Grilled chicken salad, celery, cranberries, walnuts, provolone, lettuce | $10.21 | – |
| #5 Turkey Bacon Club | Honey mesquite smoked turkey, smoked bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $10.65 | 800 |
| #6 Asiago Chicken | Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, provolone, Asiago Caesar dressing | $10.76 | 860 |
| #7 Hodge Podge | Genoa salami, capicola, smoked turkey and ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $13.18 | – |
| #8 Cafe Club | Hickory smoked turkey and ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $10.65 | – |
| #9 Italian Beef | Shaved Italian beef dipped in au jus, spicy giardiniera peppers, side of au jus | $12.08 | – |
| #10 Meatball Sub | Limited time only: meatballs, housemade marinara, mozzarella, parmesan, Italian seasoning | $12.08 | – |
| #11 Italian Club | Genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, vinegar and oil, Italian seasoning | $10.98 | 910 |
| #12 Smokehouse Stack | Pulled pork, smoked bacon, provolone, lettuce, onion, housemade chipotle ranch | $12.08 | – |
| #13 B.L.T.C. | Double stack of smoked bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $9.88 | – |
| #14 BBQ Pulled Pork | Pulled pork, provolone, pickles, onions, BBQ sauce | $10.65 | – |
| #15 Buffalo Chicken | Grilled chicken, provolone, bleu cheese crumbles, buffalo sauce, lettuce, housemade ranch | $10.76 | – |
| #16 Grilled Cheese | Fresh sliced provolone and mozzarella, pairs well with the Tomato Basil Bisque | $7.13 | 640 |
| #17 Chipotle Chicken | Grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, housemade chipotle ranch | $10.76 | 750 |
The Sandwich Combo Meal, any toasted sandwich plus a side and fountain drink, runs about $12.48. And if you are feeding coworkers, the MealBoxes, one sandwich with a side and drink packed in a box, run $12.00 each at most locations.
My Pick: #11 Italian Club
🍕 Pickleman’s Pizza Menu Prices: Thin-Crust Worth Trying?
Yes, the pizzas are genuinely good, which is not something I say about sandwich shops. Pickleman’s does 12″ thin tavern-style crusts plus 10″ gluten-friendly cauliflower crusts. The chicken on these is all No Antibiotics Ever, which is rare at this price point.
The Hog is the heavyweight, grilled chicken, pepperoni, Italian sausage, giardiniera peppers, onions, the works. My honest take: the pepperoni pizza punches above its price, and the Asiago Chicken pizza is the sleeper hit.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza | Artisan cheese blend, housemade marinara, parmesan, Italian seasoning | $13.18 | – |
| Pepperoni Pizza | Pepperoni, cheese blend, housemade marinara, parmesan, Italian seasoning | $14.28 | 1310 |
| Italian Sausage Pizza | Italian sausage, cheese blend, housemade marinara, parmesan, Italian seasoning | $15.38 | – |
| Veggie Pizza | Spinach, black olives, tomatoes, giardiniera peppers, cheese blend, marinara | $16.48 | – |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza | Grilled chicken (NAE), cheese blend, BBQ sauce, parmesan | $17.69 | – |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | Grilled chicken (NAE), bleu cheese crumbles, cheese blend, buffalo sauce, parmesan | $18.68 | – |
| Asiago Chicken Pizza | Grilled chicken (NAE), crumbled bacon, cheese blend, Asiago Caesar dressing, parmesan | $19.78 | – |
| Chipotle Beef Pizza | Shaved Italian beef, pepperoni, cheese blend, housemade chipotle ranch, parmesan | $22.53 | – |
| The Hog Pizza | Grilled chicken (NAE), pepperoni, Italian sausage, giardiniera peppers, onions, cheese blend, marinara | $23.08 | – |
🥗 Are Pickleman’s Salads Any Good?
Surprisingly, yes. The salads come in half and full sizes with dressing on the side, and the Walnut Cran salad, spinach, dried cranberries, walnuts, bleu cheese, hard-boiled egg, balsamic vinaigrette, is one of the better fast-casual salads I have had under ten bucks. The Chop salads are built on romaine with house-made dressings like Twisted Citrus and Chipotle Ranch.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garden Chop Salad | Romaine, cheddar, banana peppers, olives, cucumber, tomato, croutons, Italian vinaigrette | $7.13 | – |
| Asiago Caesar Salad | Romaine, parmesan, croutons, Asiago Caesar dressing | $7.46 | 260 |
| Walnut Cran Salad | Spinach, dried cranberries, walnuts, bleu cheese, hard-boiled egg, balsamic vinaigrette | $8.01 | – |
| Buffalo Chicken Salad | Romaine, grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, bleu cheese, mozzarella, ranch | $8.45 | – |
| Cafe Chop Salad | Romaine, smoked turkey and ham, cheddar, cucumber, tomato, croutons, chipotle ranch | $8.78 | – |
| Avo-Cobb Salad | Romaine, smoked bacon, cheddar, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, croutons, ranch | $9.11 | – |
| Italian Chop Salad | Romaine, genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, mozzarella, giardiniera, Twisted Citrus dressing | $9.33 | – |
| Chicken Caesar Salad | Romaine, NAE grilled chicken, parmesan, garlic croutons, Asiago Caesar dressing | $8.78 | – |
🍲 What Soups Does Pickleman’s Serve?
Three soups, all served with a chunk of their artisan bread. They come in 8-ounce and 12-ounce portions. The Broccoli Cheese is the fan favorite, rich cheddar, real broccoli, and you get that bread chunk to dunk. The Tomato Basil Bisque is the classic grilled-cheese companion, and the Loaded Baked Potato is a limited-time rotation item, so grab it when you see it.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tomato Basil Bisque | Caramelized onions, red pepper flakes, artisan bread chunk; 8 oz / 12 oz | $6.58 / $8.23 | 280 |
| Broccoli Cheese | Rich cheddar cheese soup with fresh broccoli, artisan bread chunk; 8 oz / 12 oz | $6.58 / $8.23 | – |
| Loaded Baked Potato | Limited time only: creamy potato soup, bacon bits, chives; 8 oz / 12 oz | $6.58 / $8.23 | – |
🧀 Mac & Cheese Bowls: Comfort in a Bowl
Don’t sleep on the mac & cheese. It starts as creamy white cheddar mac, then you can load it up. Six bowls on the menu now, and the Buffalo Chicken and Chipotle Chicken versions are legitimately dinner-worthy. A plain bowl is the cheapest hot item on the menu after soup, which makes it the budget move for a filling lunch.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mac & Cheese | Creamy white cheddar mac and cheese | $6.91 | 360 |
| BBQ Pulled Pork | Pulled pork (NAE), BBQ sauce over white cheddar mac | $9.88 | – |
| Spicy Pork | Pulled pork (NAE), giardiniera peppers, chipotle ranch over mac | $10.21 | – |
| Buffalo Chicken | Grilled chicken (NAE), bleu cheese crumbles, buffalo sauce, ranch over mac | $10.76 | – |
| Chipotle Chicken | Grilled chicken (NAE), giardiniera peppers, chipotle ranch over mac | $10.76 | – |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | Grilled chicken (NAE), smoked bacon, housemade ranch over mac | $10.76 | – |
🍪 Sides, Kids Menu & Drinks
The sides menu reads like a greatest-hits of snacks. The Garlic Cheese Bread, mozzarella and whipped garlic butter on a white roll with marinara, is the side that disappears from the table first. Chocolate chip cookies are baked from scratch daily. For drinks, the 3-ingredient non-GMO lemonade and strawberry lemonade have a loyal following, plus fountain sodas, sweet and unsweet organic black tea, and kids drinks like Honest Kids apple juice.
The Kids Menu is simple: any half sandwich with a side and a kids drink, which keeps little ones happy without the price of a full order.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Cheese Bread | Mozzarella, whipped garlic butter, white artisan roll, marinara side | $8.23 | – |
| Kettle-Cooked Chips | Non-GMO chips, a percentage of each bag supports Brave Like McKenna Foundation | $2.49 | – |
| Pickles | Fresh classic dill pickles, whole or half | $1.99 | – |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | Made from scratch, baked fresh daily | $1.74 | – |
| Chicken Salad (side) | Housemade chicken salad with NAE grilled chicken, celery, cranberries, walnuts | $6.58 | – |
| Giardiniera Peppers (jar) | Spicy pepper mix with carrots, cauliflower, serrano peppers | $7.99 | – |
| Kids Menu | Half sandwich with a side and kids drink | $6.58 | – |
| Fountain Beverage | Coke products | $3.28 | – |
| Sweet / Unsweet Tea | USDA Organic Rishi black tea, sweetened with pure cane sugar | $3.28 | – |
| Lemonade / Strawberry Lemonade | 3-ingredient non-GMO lemonade, strawberry with real puree | $3.49 | – |
🔥 Nutrition Information: What’s in a Pickleman’s Sandwich?
Pickleman’s publishes calorie counts for popular items, which puts it ahead of a lot of sandwich shops its size. The official Pickleman’s nutrition PDF lists full macros for the whole menu. Here are the headline numbers.
On the light end, the Asiago Caesar Salad runs about 260 calories and the Tomato Basil Bisque about 280, both solid choices if you are watching intake. A #1 Turkey sandwich lands around 640 calories, pretty reasonable for a full toasted sandwich. On the indulgent side, the #11 Italian Club hits about 910 calories, the #6 Asiago Chicken about 860, and a full pepperoni pizza reaches about 1,310.
The whole menu carries No Antibiotics Ever chicken and pulled pork, and the kitchen runs a no-fryer policy, so nothing is deep-fried. You can find the full Pickleman’s nutrition PDF on the official Pickleman’s website.
💰 Deals & Money-Saving Tips: How to Pay Less at Pickleman’s
Pickleman’s isn’t a coupon-heavy chain like the pizza giants, but there are real ways to save. Here is what actually works.
1. Get the Pickleman’s app. The official app carries exclusive offers and makes ordering for pickup faster. Pickup is meaningfully cheaper than delivery apps, which run 10 to 20 percent above in-store prices.
2. Combo and MealBox it. The Sandwich Combo Meal at about $12.48 beats buying a sandwich, side and drink separately. The MealBoxes at $12.00 are the best deal if you grab lunch there often.
3. Watch DoorDash promos. Delivery listings regularly show deals like 20% off orders over $30 and zero delivery fee on the first order. If you are ordering for the office, that stacks fast.
4. Go for the mac bowls and soup. A plain Mac & Cheese at $6.91 or a cup of soup at $6.58 is the cheapest hot lunch in the building, and both are genuinely filling.
5. Catering for groups. Pickleman’s does group and office catering with sandwich trays and box lunches. If you are feeding a team, the per-person cost beats ordering individually, and many locations take catering orders through the app.
🕙 Pickleman’s Opening Hours
Pickleman’s is franchise-owned, so hours vary by location. Most cafes open at 10:00 AM daily. College-town locations, Columbia, Lawrence, Lincoln, Stillwater, often stay open late, some until 2:00 AM or 3:00 AM on weekends. Typical hours:
| Day | Typical Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM (college towns until 2–3 AM) |
| Sunday | 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
Always check the official Pickleman’s store locator before heading out, especially around holidays and academic breaks when hours shift.
🏠 About Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe
Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe was founded in 2005 in Columbia, Missouri by Doug Stritzel, the former COO of Jimmy John’s, who wanted a better sandwich and pizza experience built on fresh ingredients. The company is headquartered in Columbia, Missouri and operates under Pickleman’s Holdings, LLC.
The concept is fast-casual with a better-for-you slant: produce prepped daily, 7-ingredient bread with no dough conditioners, No Antibiotics Ever chicken and pork, and a strict no-fryer kitchen policy. From its Missouri roots, Pickleman’s has grown to more than 35 locations across Missouri, Kansas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Indiana, Nebraska, and Texas, with expansion pushing into the Dallas-Fort Worth area. Franchise owners set their own prices, which is why totals can vary 10 to 20 percent between locations.
❓ picklemans cafe menu FAQ
What is the most popular item at Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe?
The #11 Italian Club is the most popular item, genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, pepperoni, provolone, and Italian seasoning on toasted bread for $10.98.
What is the cheapest item at Pickleman’s?
The chocolate chip cookie at $1.74 is the cheapest menu item. Among full meals, a cup of Tomato Basil Bisque or Broccoli Cheese soup at $6.58 and the plain Mac & Cheese at $6.91 are the cheapest hot options.
Are Pickleman’s prices the same at every location?
No. Pickleman’s is franchise-owned, so each owner sets prices. Totals can vary 10 to 20 percent between locations, and delivery apps run above in-store prices. The prices here are the 2026 national average from Columbia, Missouri base pricing.
Does Pickleman’s deliver?
Yes. Most locations deliver through DoorDash, Uber Eats and Postmates, and the brand takes direct orders through its own website and app. Pickup through the app is cheaper than delivery platforms.
What are the cheapest sandwiches at Pickleman’s?
The #16 Grilled Cheese at $7.13 is the cheapest sandwich, followed by the #3 Veggie at $8.23 and the #2 Ham at $9.33. All seventeen sandwiches run $7.13 to $13.18.
Does Pickleman’s have a nutrition PDF?
Yes. Pickleman’s publishes a nutrition PDF with full calorie and macro counts for the whole menu on the official Pickleman’s website. Popular counts include the #1 Turkey at 640 calories and the pepperoni pizza at 1,310 calories.
What are Pickleman’s catering prices for 2026?
Pickleman’s offers group and office catering with sandwich trays, box lunches and MealBoxes at $12.00 each. For group and office orders, the catering guide on the official website covers sizing and lead times. Ordering a tray for a group beats the per-person cost of individual orders.
Where can I find Pickleman’s locations near me?
Pickleman’s has 35+ locations across Missouri, Kansas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Indiana, Nebraska, and Texas. Use the official Pickleman’s store locator on picklemans.com for the current list and addresses near you.
What is the #11 Italian Club sandwich price at Pickleman’s?
The #11 Italian Club costs $10.98. It is loaded with genoa salami, capicola, smoked ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, vinegar and oil, and Italian seasoning on toasted bread, at about 910 calories.
Does Pickleman’s have gluten-free options?
Yes. Pizzas come on 10″ gluten-friendly cauliflower crusts, any sandwich can be made as a romaine lettuce wrap, and several salads are naturally lighter options. The official nutrition PDF lists full allergen information.
Prices last verified: 2026-10-24. Menu items and prices sourced from the official Pickleman’s menu page at picklemans.com/menu, with pricing from published 2026 listings. Prices may vary by location and are subject to change.
📍 Find Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe Near You
Type your city into the map to find the nearest Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe:
⭐ Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.4/5 across flagship locations, with over 1,100 reviews at the Springfield, Missouri store alone.
Customers consistently praise the toasted sandwiches, especially the Italian Club, the homemade ranch dressing, fresh ingredients, and value pricing that beats the big sub chains. The broccoli cheddar soup and thin-crust pizzas get frequent shoutouts too. Criticisms tend to focus on delivery orders arriving cold and occasional small portions at certain franchises.
