Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu Guide 2026
Papa Murphy’s secret menu isn’t a hidden printed menu. It’s a collection of off-menu hacks, take-and-bake tricks, seasonal shape pizzas, and custom crust and topping combos you can request at the counter. Most cost nothing extra or only small upcharges, and several come straight from the company’s own “Hub of Hacks” playbook.
If you’ve already browsed the Papa Murphy’s menu with prices, you know the deal: you pick it up raw and bake it at home. But here’s the thing most regulars never figure out. Because the pizza leaves the store unbaked, you can do things with it that would be impossible at a normal delivery chain. Cut it up before it hits the oven. Roll it into pinwheels. Twist it into dippers. I’ll walk you through the best-kept secrets, what to ask for, and what each one costs.
🍕 So What’s Actually on Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu?
Short answer: there’s no laminated “secret menu” hanging behind the register. Papa Murphy’s sells take-and-bake pizzas, so the real secret menu lives in two places: the official Hub of Hacks on their own website, and the tricks long-time fans have worked out at the counter.
The Hub of Hacks is where the company posts recipes for turning their pizzas into other foods. Pizza muffins, grilled cheese pizza sandwiches, cinnamon dippers from a Mini Murph kit, jalapeno cheese bread made from their 5-Cheese Bread. These aren’t rumors. They’re posted on papamurphys.com with step-by-step instructions.
Then there’s the stuff you do yourself. Split one pizza into two custom halves. Ask for a stuffed crust on a signature pizza. Swap the regular cheese for dairy-free Violife. Because everything is made fresh in the store and baked by YOU, the staff are pretty relaxed about oddball requests.
🔥 What Are the Best Papa Murphy’s Pizza Hacks?
These are the ones worth trying first, and most use a pizza you can buy right now off the full Papa Murphy’s menu with prices.
The Perfect Spiral (Stuffed Pizza Pull-Aparts)
Grab any Stuffed pizza and a sharp knife. Cut strips from the edge toward the center, about 1.5 inches wide, then twist each strip two or three times and press it down. Bake per the stuffed instructions. You get a pull-apart spiral bread that feeds a crowd at a party. This one looks seriously impressive.
Pizza Muffins
Take a large Original crust pizza and cut the whole unbaked thing into 3-inch squares. Grease a muffin pan, press each square in to form a cup, and bake 10 to 12 minutes at 425 degrees until golden. Great for game day or kids who want their own little pizza.
Grilled Cheese Pizza Sandwich
Leftover pizza? Best hack in the book. Sandwich two baked slices together cheese-to-cheese, butter the crust sides, and fry in a covered pan on low for 5 to 7 minutes per side. Crispy, melty, gone in about three minutes.
Pizza Twists, Rolls, and Cookie Cutter Shapes
Cut an unbaked Original crust pizza into strips, twist them, and bake for handheld pizza sticks. Or roll the whole chilled pizza into a tight log, slice it into rounds, let them rise 30 minutes, and bake at 425 for pinwheel-style pizza rolls. With a cookie cutter you can stamp the raw dough into fun shapes for kids.
Cinnamon Dippers and Breakfast Pizza
Reshape a Mini Murph pizza dough into a square, cut 1/2-inch strips, twist, bake at 375 for 8 to 10 minutes, then brush with butter and cinnamon sugar. Serve with cream cheese frosting. And if you ever have yesterday’s pizza for breakfast, crack an egg over a slice and bake. Breakfast pizza, done.
❤️ Can You Get Seasonal Shape Pizzas Off the Menu?
Yes, and these are the closest thing to a true limited secret menu. Papa Murphy’s rolls out shape pizzas around holidays:
| Seasonal Shape | Holiday | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Heartbaker Pizza | Valentine’s Day | Heart-shaped pizza, usually offered on regular and Mini Murph sizes |
| Jack O’Lantern Pizza | Halloween | Pizza shaped and decorated like a jack-o-lantern |
| Detroit-Style Pizza | Limited time | Thick rectangular pan pizza with crispy cheese edges, launched at $10.99 |
These usually run on the regular menu price, not a premium. They come and go fast, though. If you see one posted in-store or on the app, grab it. They don’t always come back next year.
🛒 What Custom Orders Can You Hack at the Counter?
Ordering tricks are where the everyday “hidden menu” lives. Papa Murphy’s builds each pizza to order, so try these:
Crust swaps. Put a signature pizza on Thin, Stuffed, or Original crust even if it isn’t listed that way. The staff can usually do it. Gluten-free crust is available for most pizzas too.
Go crustless (keto-style). Order a “create your own” crustless pizza and load it with toppings and cheese. Low-carb fans have been doing this for years.
Dairy-free cheese. They carry Violife dairy-free cheese. You can get it on most pizzas, and it melts surprisingly well.
Sauce swaps and doubles. Ask for a different sauce than the pizza normally comes with, or ask them to go heavy or light. The made-from-scratch sauces are free to mix.
Split a pizza into two styles. Order one large with different topping combos on each half. You’re basically getting two off-menu pizzas for the price of one.
Jalapeno cheese bread. This one’s from the official playbook: buy the 5-Cheese Bread, sprinkle sliced jalapenos on top before baking, and you’ve got a spicy off-menu side.
💲 How Much Do Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu Hacks Cost?
Good news: most of them cost nothing extra. Reshaping, re-cutting, or re-baking a pizza you already bought is free. The counter tricks usually run at regular menu prices too, with only small upcharges for things like stuffed crust or dairy-free cheese, and those vary by location.
Seasonal shape pizzas are priced like a regular pizza of that size. The Mini Murph kit for the cinnamon dippers is one of the cheapest things on the menu. And the Detroit-Style launch was priced at just $10.99, which is honestly a steal for a thick pan pizza. Want the numbers? Check the Papa Murphy’s menu with current 2026 prices to plan your hack order.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does Papa Murphy’s have an official secret menu?
Not a printed one. The closest thing is their official “Hub of Hacks” on papamurphys.com, which lists off-menu recipe ideas like spiral stuffed pizzas, pizza muffins, and grilled cheese pizza sandwiches, plus the custom orders you can make at the counter.
How do I order a Papa Murphy’s secret menu item?
Describe what you want instead of using a code name. Say “can I get a large Pepperoni on a stuffed crust?” or “can you split that pizza with different toppings on each half?” The staff build pizzas to order, so most requests are no problem.
What is the Heartbaker pizza at Papa Murphy’s?
It’s a heart-shaped pizza Papa Murphy’s offers around Valentine’s Day, available in regular and Mini Murph sizes. They also do a Jack O’Lantern shape pizza for Halloween. Both are limited-time and priced like regular pizzas.
Do Papa Murphy’s hacks cost extra?
Most cost nothing beyond the pizza you bought, since you’re just reshaping or re-cutting it at home. Counter requests like crust swaps or dairy-free cheese may add a small upcharge depending on the location.
