Five Star Pizza Menu USA Prices 2026
How Much Is a Five Star Pizza? Build Your Own Prices
The short answer: a cheese pizza runs $17.55 to $36.45 depending on size, and every pie starts with their fresh daily-made dough. That’s the thing about Five Star, the dough is made in-store every single day, hand-tossed, with Wisconsin mozzarella and California packed tomatoes. You can taste the difference, especially on a plain cheese pie. Nothing hides behind the toppings.
Five sizes to choose from, and yes, that 24-inch Piezilla is real. It feeds a crowd. Here’s what each build-your-own size costs:
| Size | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Small 12″ | Cheese pizza, your choice of toppings | $17.55 |
| Gluten-Free 12″ | Same great taste, gluten-free crust | $18.89 |
| Large 16″ | A true 16 inches, they never shrank it | $21.59 |
| X-Large 18″ | Party-size, feeds 4 to 5 | $24.29 |
| Piezilla 24″ | The legend. Feeds 6 to 8 easily | $36.45 |
Toppings are priced per pie, and here’s my honest take: loading up a large with three or four toppings can run you more than just grabbing a Deluxe, which already comes stacked. Check the specialty list before you go full custom.
What Are Five Star Pizza’s Signature Specialty Pizzas?
Signature specialty pies run $26.99 for a large 16-inch, $32.39 for an X-large 18-inch, and $49.95 for a 24-inch Piezilla. These are the loaded, no-skimping pies, and most of them come out cheaper than building the same thing yourself. The Everything pie is a couple bucks more because it’s, well, everything.
| Item | Details | Price (Large 16″) |
|---|---|---|
| All the Meats | Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham, extra cheese | $26.99 |
| Deluxe | Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers | $26.99 |
| Pepperoni Powerhouse | Triple pepperoni, extra mozzarella | $26.99 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch drizzle | $26.99 |
| Buffalo Chicken | Buffalo chicken, cheddar and mozzarella blend | $26.99 |
| BBQ Chicken | BBQ chicken over a BBQ sauce base | $26.99 |
| Hawaiian | Ham, bacon, pineapple, the sweet and salty combo | $26.99 |
| Philly Cheesesteak | Chopped steak, peppers, onions, cheddar and mozzarella | $26.99 |
| Bacon Double Cheeseburger | Bacon, beef, cheddar, the burger that became a pizza | $26.99 |
| The Florida Man | One of their wild signature creations | $26.99 |
| Hot Honey Pepperoni | Pepperoni with a hot honey drizzle, sweet heat | $26.99 |
| The Big Dill | Pickle pizza for the pickle-obsessed | $26.99 |
| The Hamilton | Signature house creation | $26.99 |
| Meatball Parmesan | Meatballs, parmesan, red sauce | $26.99 |
| Veggie | Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes | $26.99 |
| Spinach and Feta | Spinach, feta, onions, Mediterranean style | $26.99 |
| Chicken Alfredo | Grilled chicken over creamy alfredo | $26.99 |
| Everything | The fully loaded pie, every topping they have | $29.89 |
My pick? The Deluxe. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, the classic combo done right with a crust that actually has some chew to it. The Hot Honey Pepperoni is the sleeper hit though. Sweet, spicy, crispy edges. Order it once and you’ll get it.
Do They Have Crustless Pizza Bowls?
Yes, and they’re one of the best value items on the whole menu. Pizza bowls are $11.06, crustless, baked in a bowl with all your favorite toppings and cheese. Same toppings as the pizzas, zero carbs from crust. Perfect if you’re doing low-carb or you just want the good stuff without the filler.
| Item | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Build Your Own Bowl | Any toppings, crustless, baked in a bowl | $11.06 |
| Pepperoni Powerhouse Bowl | Triple pepperoni, cheese, sauce | $11.06 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Bowl | Chicken, bacon, ranch | $11.06 |
| Buffalo Chicken Bowl | Buffalo chicken, cheese blend | $11.06 |
| BBQ Chicken Bowl | BBQ chicken over BBQ sauce | $11.06 |
| All the Meats Bowl | Every meat, no crust needed | $11.06 |
| Veggie Bowl | All the garden toppings | $11.06 |
| Philly Cheesesteak Bowl | Chopped steak, peppers, onions | $11.06 |
How Much Are Five Star Pizza Wings?
Wings run $17.55 for 10 pieces and $35.09 for 20 pieces. And here’s something worth knowing: they use Springer Mountain Farms all-natural chicken, no antibiotics, no steroids, no growth stimulants. For a pizza joint wing, that’s genuinely above average. Tossed in your choice of sauce, baked or fried depending on the location.
| Item | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 10 pc Wings | Mild, Hot, BBQ, Garlic Parm, Teriyaki, Lemon Pepper, Mango Habanero, or No Sauce | $17.55 |
| 20 pc Wings | Same sauce lineup, feeds the whole table | $35.09 |
Garlic Parm is the crowd favorite. Mango Habanero if you like your wings to fight back a little. The Lemon Pepper is criminally underrated, trust me on this one.
Sides Worth Ordering
Skipping the sides at Five Star is a mistake. The pepperoni rolls alone have a cult following, and the garlic rolls disappear the second the box opens. Here’s the full side lineup:
| Item | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic Rolls | Buttery, garlicky, dangerously easy to eat | $8.09 |
| CheesyStix | Cheesy breadsticks with marinara | $12.15 |
| Pepperoni Rolls | Stuffed with pepperoni and cheese, the legend | $10.79 |
| Chicken Bites | Over half a pound of juicy chicken, ranch, bleu cheese, BBQ, honey mustard, or buffalo dip | $14.75 |
| Jalapeno Cheese Curds | Spicy, melty, gone in minutes | $7.37 |
| Dill Pickle Cheese Curds | Tangy twist on a classic | $7.37 |
Desserts and Drinks
Save room, or don’t, the cinnamon rolls are worth ordering first and reheating later. Sweet endings and drinks run from $3.89 to $8.09.
| Item | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Cinnamon Rolls | Warm, gooey, the must-try dessert | $8.09 |
| Double Fudge Brownie | Rich chocolate, feeds two (or one, no judgment) | $8.09 |
| Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies | Available at select locations | $2.49 |
| 20 oz Bottled Drink | Pepsi products, assorted flavors | $3.89 |
| 2-Liter Bottle | For the whole crew | $5.69 |
Nutrition Information
Straight talk: Five Star Pizza doesn’t publish a detailed calorie chart online, so I can’t give you exact numbers per slice here. What I can tell you is that a slice of large cheese pizza at most pizzerias lands in the 280 to 350 calorie range, and loaded specialty slices run higher. Your best bets for lighter eating are the crustless pizza bowls, the veggie pizza, or simply going easy on the cheese and meat toppings. For the most accurate info, check with your local store or the official Five Star Pizza menu page, which is linked below as the source for these prices.
Deals and Money-Saving Tips
Five Star runs real deals, you just have to know where to look. Here’s how to pay less:
- Text coupons: sign up for their text alerts and you’ll get coupons pushed straight to your phone. Regulars swear by these, one reviewer said the text deals alone made Five Star their go-to.
- Game day specials: football season brings watch-party deals that run from September through the Super Bowl. A Piezilla plus wings bundle during a game is the move.
- Specials menu: check the Specials section on their website before ordering, limited-time offers live there.
- Delivery app promos: DoorDash frequently runs 20% off $25+ on Five Star stores, and they’re DashPass eligible, which wipes out delivery fees.
- Order direct: ordering through fivestarpizza.com skips the delivery-app markup, which can add a few dollars per item.
October bonus: every 18-inch pizza ordered in October supports breast cancer awareness, with $1 per pie going to the National Breast Cancer Foundation. Good pizza, good cause.
What Time Does Five Star Pizza Open and Close?
Typical hours are 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM daily, with Friday and Saturday running to 2:00 or 3:00 AM. The Gainesville locations near the University of Florida famously stay open until 3:30 AM, a lifesaver during late-night study sessions. Hours vary by location, so check your nearest store before heading out at midnight.
| Day | Typical Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday to Thursday | 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM – 2:00 AM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM – 2:00 AM |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM |
Delivery usually runs the full open hours. If it’s 2 AM on a Friday and you’re craving a Piezilla in Gainesville, you’re in luck.
About Five Star Pizza
John Gillespie opened the first Five Star Pizza in Gainesville, Florida in 1988 with one mission: deliver a great pizza fast, any time of day or night. University of Florida students made it an instant legend, and the chain grew across Florida, from Sarasota to Jacksonville, Ocala to Ormond Beach, now 20+ locations and counting. Every store makes its dough fresh daily, hand-tosses each pie, shreds Wisconsin mozzarella and slices vegetables fresh every day. While competitors quietly shrank their large pizzas over the years, Five Star kept theirs a true 16 inches and added 18 and 24-inch options for good measure. Bigger, better, faster is the promise, and after nearly four decades, it still holds up.
Five Star Pizza Menu FAQs
What is the most popular item on the Five Star Pizza menu?
The All the Meats and the Deluxe are the two most-ordered pies, both $26.99 for a large 16-inch. DoorDash data also shows the plain large cheese pizza ($21.59) and the 10-piece wings ($17.55) among the top sellers. If you’re ordering for the first time, the Deluxe is the safest bet, it’s the classic combo that shows off what their crust and sauce can do.
What is the cheapest item at Five Star Pizza?
The cheapest menu items are the Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies at $2.49 (select locations) and the jalapeno or dill pickle cheese curds at $7.37. For actual pizza, the small 12-inch build-your-own at $17.55 is the lowest-priced pie. The 20-ounce drinks run $3.89, making a cookie and a drink the cheapest possible order.
How much is the 24-inch Piezilla at Five Star Pizza?
A cheese Piezilla is $36.45, and a loaded specialty Piezilla (All the Meats, Deluxe, Buffalo Chicken, and the rest) runs $49.95. It feeds 6 to 8 people easily, so per person it’s one of the best values on the menu. Game day? This is your move.
Does Five Star Pizza deliver?
Yes. Five Star offers its own delivery from most locations, plus DoorDash and other apps, and they’re famous for late-night delivery, some stores run until 2:00 or 3:00 AM. Delivery prices on apps run a bit higher than in-store, so ordering direct from fivestarpizza.com saves a few dollars.
Does Five Star Pizza have a secret menu?
There’s no official secret menu, but regulars have their hacks: order a pizza bowl crustless with buffalo chicken for a low-carb wing-pizza hybrid, or ask for the Big Dill with extra pickles if you’re pickle-obsessed. The staff are friendly about custom orders, so don’t be shy about building something off-script.
What are Five Star Pizza’s hours?
Most locations open 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM daily, extending to 2:00 or 3:00 AM on Friday and Saturday. Gainesville stores near the University of Florida stay open until 3:30 AM. Hours vary by location, so confirm with your nearest store.
Does Five Star Pizza have gluten-free pizza?
Yes, a 12-inch gluten-free pizza is available for $18.89. It’s made on the same line as regular pizzas, so if you have a severe allergy or celiac disease, it’s worth asking the store about their prep process.
Are there healthy options at Five Star Pizza?
The crustless pizza bowls ($11.06) are the standout healthy pick, all the toppings and cheese with none of the crust carbs. The veggie pizza and the spinach and feta specialty are lighter choices too, and you can always load up on veggies while going light on cheese and meat.
Does Five Star Pizza offer coupons or deals?
Yes, and the text-coupon program is the big one, sign up and deals land on your phone. They also run football-season game day specials through the Super Bowl, post limited-time offers on their website’s Specials menu, and DoorDash frequently discounts them (20% off $25+ shows up often). Some locations have loyalty-style rewards, ask at the counter.
Where can I find Five Star Pizza locations near me?
Five Star Pizza has 20+ locations across Florida, from Sarasota to Jacksonville and Ocala to Ormond Beach, with heavy coverage in Gainesville, Jacksonville, and Tampa. Use the map below or search “Five Star Pizza near me” on Google Maps to find your closest store.
Prices last verified: October 20, 2026. Source: fivestarpizza.com (official menu) and current delivery listings.
📍 Find Five Star Pizza Near You
⭐ Five Star Pizza Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.4/5
Customers consistently praise the fresh hand-tossed crust, generous toppings, and the legendary late-night hours. The pepperoni rolls and garlic rolls get called out by name in review after review, and UF students have kept Gainesville locations packed for decades. Common gripes: delivery-app prices run higher than ordering direct, and busy late nights can mean longer waits.
