Blasdell Pizza Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the Blasdell Pizza menu, you landed at the right place. Here you can explore the full Blasdell Pizza menu prices for 2026, every category, exact prices and the dishes this family-run Buffalo-area chain is famous for. All prices below are national averages pulled from their current menu, and they do vary a bit by location. Blasdell Pizza is one of those Western New York gems you either grew up on or wish you had. Four locations, one big Italian family, and a menu that refuses to keep things simple: pizza, wings, fingers, subs, tacos, salads, the works. I broke everything down below, so you know exactly what dinner will cost before you pick up the phone.
Blasdell Pizza Menu Prices: What Does a Large Cost?
As an Amazon Associate, MenuPrice earns from qualifying purchases.
A large 17-inch Blasdell Pizza specialty pie costs $39.36 in 2026, and honestly that is the headline number you need. The chain’s cup-and-char style is pure Buffalo, and at this price you are feeding 3-4 hungry people. Slices start at $4.44 if you just want a quick bite, and the size lineup runs from a personal 9-incher up to a party-ready sheet.
🍕 Pizza by the Slice
Three slices on the menu, all $4.44. Nothing fancy, just a hot slice when you need one fast. The pepperoni slice is my pick, the cups get crispy at the edges and it eats like a much pricier pie.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Slice | Classic red sauce, mozzarella blend | $4.44 | ~290 |
| Pepperoni Slice | Cup-and-char pepperoni, most popular slice | $4.44 | ~320 |
| Sweet Sauce Slice | Sweeter red sauce, Buffalo tradition | $4.44 | ~300 |
Build Your Own Pizza: Sizes and Prices
A build-your-own starts at $11.42 for a personal 9-inch and tops out around $51.19 for a sheet cheese, toppings extra. The small 14-inch at $21.58 is the sweet spot for two people, and there is a 10-inch gluten free crust at $19.68 if you need it.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal 9″ Cheese | Cheese or add your favorite toppings, 4 slices | $11.42 | ~1050 |
| Small 14″ Cheese | Cheese or add your favorite toppings, 8 slices | $21.58 | ~1680 |
| Large 17″ Cheese | Cheese or add your favorite toppings, 12 slices | $28.56 | ~2900 |
| Gluten Free 10″ | Cauliflower crust, cheese or your toppings | $19.68 | ~980 |
| Sheet Cheese | Party size, cheese or add toppings | $50.79 | ~6400 |
Gourmet Specialty Pizzas: Which Blasdell Pizza Is Worth Ordering?
The specialty lineup is where Blasdell Pizza earns its local-legend status. Nine gourmet pies, headlined by the Chicken Finger Pizza ($39.36 large) and the famous Papa Harry’s Super Steak ($41.90 large), which layers 4 cheeses, mushrooms, onions and hot or sweet peppers. The Pickle Pizza is the wild card. Sounds odd, tastes incredible, get it at least once.
| Item | Details | Large 17″ | Small 14″ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken Finger Pizza | Red sauce, cheese blend, diced chicken fingers (mild, medium or hot) | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Pickle Pizza | Dill pickle, cheese blend, the cult favorite | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Taco Pizza | Ground beef, salsa, lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, Monterey Jack | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| White Pizza | Olive oil, garlic, fresh tomatoes, roasted peppers, onion, cheese blend | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Chicken Deluxe | Olive oil, garlic, marinated chicken, roasted peppers, broccoli | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Chicken & Spinach | Olive oil, fresh tomatoes, spinach, onion, mozzarella & fontinella | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Vegetable Pizza | Olive oil, roasted peppers, broccoli, mushrooms, onions | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Stuffed Pepper Pizza | Stuffed hot peppers, cheese blend, a Buffalo signature | $39.36 | $31.74 |
| Papa Harry’s Super Steak | 4 cheeses, mushrooms, onions, hot or sweet peppers, steak | $41.90 | $33.01 |
Personal 9-inch versions of every specialty run $19.04 ($20.31 for Papa Harry’s), and sheet sizes run $64.76 ($68.57 for Papa Harry’s). Ordering for a crowd? The sheet is the move, it feeds 12-15 people for about the price of two larges.
Chicken Wings: What Are the Prices?
Wings are the second star of the Blasdell Pizza menu prices conversation. A single order of traditional wings is $21.58, doubles run $39.36 and a bucket hits $74.92 for the big game night. Boneless wings start at $19.04 for a single and go to $62.22 for a bucket. Sauces come mild, medium or hot, and the bleu cheese is non-negotiable in Buffalo. Trust me on that.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Wings | Traditional bone-in, your choice of sauce, bleu cheese & celery | $21.58 | ~1100 |
| Double Wings | Double order, great for sharing | $39.36 | ~2200 |
| Triple Wings | Party quantity | $53.33 | ~3300 |
| Bucket Wings | The full bucket, feeds a crowd | $74.92 | ~5200 |
| Boneless Wings Single | Boneless, tossed in your sauce | $19.04 | ~950 |
| Boneless Wings Double | Double boneless order | $33.01 | ~1900 |
| Boneless Wings Triple | Triple boneless order | $41.90 | ~2850 |
| Boneless Bucket | Full boneless bucket | $62.22 | ~4300 |
Chicken Fingers: Buffalo’s Other Obsession
3 fingers for $12.79, 5 for $24.12 and 10 for $38.09. The chicken finger sub ($15.23) is one of the most ordered items at Blasdell Pizza, crispy fingers tossed in your wing sauce with lettuce, tomato, white American and ranch. It is messy. It is perfect.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Fingers | Crispy chicken fingers with sauce of choice | $12.79 | ~620 |
| 5 Fingers | 5-piece order, the crowd favorite | $24.12 | ~1030 |
| 10 Fingers | Shareable 10-piece, best value | $38.09 | ~2060 |
| 2 Kids Fingers | Smaller 2-piece for the little ones | $12.69 | ~420 |
Subs, Hoagies and the Stinger: Are They Good?
Whole subs at Blasdell Pizza run $13.96 to $20.31 in 2026, all toasted with lettuce, tomato and cheese, oil or mayo on request. The Chicken Finger Sub ($15.23) and the Stinger ($19.04, chicken finger meets steak, a Buffalo original) are the two you should try first. Steak hoagies start around $16.50.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turkey Sub | Oven-roasted turkey, toasted | $13.96 | ~780 |
| Chicken Finger Sub | Crispy fingers, wing sauce, lettuce, tomato, ranch | $15.23 | ~1050 |
| Ham / Salami / Tuna Sub | Classic cold-cut subs, toasted | $16.50 | ~800-950 |
| Pizza Sub / Meatball Sub | Baked with cheese, pizza or meatball | $16.50 | ~950-1050 |
| Chicken Parmesan Sub | Chicken patty, provolone, romano, sauce | $17.65 | ~1100 |
| Royal Sub | Sausage & cappicola combo | $17.65 | ~1150 |
| Cheeseburger Sub | 10oz black angus beef, melted cheese | $18.40 | ~1250 |
| Stinger Sub | Chicken finger + steak, the Buffalo icon | $19.04 | ~1350 |
| Steak Deluxe Hoagie | Loaded steak hoagie | $16.50 | ~1200 |
| Bacon Cheeseburger Sub | 10oz angus, bacon, cheese | $20.31 | ~1400 |
Tacos, Salads and Sides
Yes, tacos at a pizza place. Blasdell Pizza’s beef taco salad ($13.81) gets called the best around by regulars, and honestly it is a sleeper hit. Salads come with breadsticks, and the sides cover all the Buffalo staples: pizza logs, mozzarella sticks, breadsticks and fries.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beef Taco | Seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato, cheese | $7.17 | ~350 |
| Grilled Chicken Taco | Grilled chicken, fresh fixings | $7.17 | ~320 |
| Steak Taco | Steak, lettuce, tomato, cheese | $8.69 | ~380 |
| Beef Taco Salad | Crispy shell, beef, all the fixings | $13.81 | ~850 |
| Chicken Taco Salad | Crispy shell, grilled chicken, all the fixings | $13.81 | ~800 |
| Chef Salad | Lettuce, meat, eggs, vegetables, breadsticks | $11.00 | ~550 |
| Chicken Salad | Grilled chicken over fresh greens | $15.00 | ~520 |
| Souvlaki Salad | Greek-style with souvlaki seasoning | $12.15 | ~480 |
| Small Fries | Served with bleu cheese & celery | $4.69 | ~380 |
| Large Fries | Shareable large | $7.86 | ~680 |
| Breadsticks (5pc) | Served with sauce | $5.11 | ~700 |
| Garlic Bread w/ Cheese | Toasted, loaded with cheese | $6.39 | ~800 |
| Mozzarella Sticks (5pc) | Fried, marinara for dipping | $10.23 | ~850 |
| Mozzarella Sticks (10pc) | Double order | $16.63 | ~1700 |
| Pizza Logs (4pc) | Buffalo classic, cheese & sauce inside | $11.51 | ~900 |
| Pizza Logs (8pc) | Shareable order | $20.47 | ~1800 |
| Onion Rings | Crispy, golden | $6.39 | ~550 |
Note: Blasdell Pizza does not publish official nutrition data, so calorie counts above are typical estimates for comparable items, not lab-tested values.
Nutrition Information
Blasdell Pizza does not publish an official nutrition PDF or calorie chart, which is normal for a small regional chain. Here is the honest picture: a single cheese slice lands around 290 calories, a pepperoni slice about 320, and a whole large cheese pizza runs close to 2,900 calories total. The 10-inch gluten free crust is your lightest pizza option at roughly 980 calories for the whole pie. Wings and fingers are the heavy hitters, a bucket of wings can clear 5,000 calories, so split those. If you are watching intake, go with the Chicken Salad (around 520) or the Souvlaki Salad (around 480). Every salad comes with breadsticks, which adds a few hundred, skip them if you are counting.
Deals & Money-Saving Tips
The smartest way to save at Blasdell Pizza? Start with the monthly specials. Here is what to watch for in 2026.
- Sub of the Month ($15.99): A rotating premium sub at a flat discount price. Hot Sub of the Month runs $16.63 and Cold Sub of the Month $14.07. Ask what is featured this month, it changes and it is usually one of the $18+ subs.
- Pizza of the Month (around $39.67): A rotating large specialty pie at the standard specialty price with premium toppings thrown in. Past versions have featured loaded combos you will not find on the regular menu.
- DoorDash deals: Watch for $5 off orders of $40+ on delivery apps, and Pepsi runs like $3 off $20+ with code PEPSI3. These stack on top of already-decent prices.
- Feed a crowd with a sheet: A sheet gourmet pizza ($64.76) feeds 12-15 people. Per-person, that is $4-5 each, which beats nearly any other option on the menu.
- Order direct when you can: Delivery-app prices carry a markup over in-store pricing. Calling the store or ordering pickup keeps more money in your pocket.
- Tuesday pizza deals: Regulars mention small-pizza Tuesday specials. Ask your location, this one varies by store.
Opening Hours
Blasdell Pizza opens at 11AM every day of the week in 2026. Weeknights close at 9PM, while Friday and Saturday stretch to 10PM for the late crowd. Here are the typical hours:
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
Holiday hours can differ, so call ahead on major holidays. Lunch rush hits around noon, dinner rush 5-7PM, plan accordingly.
About Blasdell Pizza
Blasdell Pizza is run by a large Italian family and has been feeding Western New York from four locations: Blasdell, Buffalo, Hamburg and Dunkirk, New York. It is the kind of place where the menu grew over the years from pizza into wings, chicken fingers, subs, hoagies, wraps, tacos and salads, because regulars kept asking for more. The Hamburg store at 4837 Southwestern Boulevard is the busiest, and the Dunkirk location even opens at 7:30AM. No corporate HQ, no franchise empire, just family-run pizzerias doing Buffalo food the way it is supposed to be done.
Blasdell Pizza Menu FAQs
What is the most popular item on the Blasdell Pizza menu?
The Chicken Finger Pizza is the signature pie, diced chicken fingers on a red-sauce cheese blend. Regulars also swear by the beef taco salad and Papa Harry’s Super Steak pizza. On delivery apps, the large cheese pizza is the most ordered item overall.
What is the cheapest item at Blasdell Pizza?
Pizza slices at $4.44 are the cheapest way to eat here: cheese, pepperoni or sweet sauce. The small fries at $4.69 are next cheapest. If you are really stretching a dollar, one slice and a small fries gets you out the door under $10.
How much is a large 17-inch pizza at Blasdell Pizza?
A large 17-inch specialty pizza costs $39.36 in 2026. Papa Harry’s Super Steak runs $41.90. A large cheese build-your-own is $28.56 before extra toppings.
Do Blasdell Pizza menu prices vary by location?
Yes. Prices differ slightly between the Blasdell, Buffalo, Hamburg and Dunkirk stores, and delivery-app prices carry a markup over in-store pricing. The prices in this article are national averages based on the current menu, so your store may be a dollar or two off either way.
Does Blasdell Pizza deliver?
Yes, Blasdell Pizza delivers through DoorDash and similar apps, with options for pickup and dine-in too. Ordering pickup directly from the store is usually cheaper than delivery-app pricing.
Does Blasdell Pizza offer catering or party sizes?
Sheet pizzas ($64.76 for gourmet, $68.57 for Papa Harry’s) feed 12-15 people and are the go-to party option. Buckets of wings ($74.92 traditional, $62.22 boneless) and 10-piece finger orders ($38.09) round out a spread. Call your location ahead for large party orders.
What are Blasdell Pizza’s hours?
Most locations open 11AM to 9PM Sunday through Thursday, and 11AM to 10PM on Friday and Saturday. The Dunkirk store opens as early as 7:30AM. Hours can vary by location and on holidays, so call ahead.
Does Blasdell Pizza have gluten-free options?
Yes, a 10-inch gluten free pizza with a cauliflower crust runs $19.68, available as cheese or with your choice of toppings, including the gourmet specialty varieties.
What deals does Blasdell Pizza run?
The Sub of the Month ($15.99), Hot Sub of the Month ($16.63) and Cold Sub of the Month ($14.07) rotate regularly. Delivery apps run deals like $5 off $40+, and regulars report small-pizza Tuesday specials at some locations. Ask your store what is running this month.
Is there nutrition information for Blasdell Pizza?
Blasdell Pizza does not publish official nutrition data. A cheese slice is roughly 290 calories, a pepperoni slice about 320, and a whole large cheese pizza close to 2,900 calories. Salads like the Chicken Salad (around 520) are the lightest full meals.
Prices last verified: October 20, 2026. Source of truth: the brand’s current store menu on DoorDash.
📍 Find Blasdell Pizza Near You
Locations: 4837 Southwestern Blvd, Hamburg, NY 14075 (716) 649-9090 • 3904 South Park Ave, Blasdell, NY 14219 (716) 822-1138 • 1170 Central Ave, Dunkirk, NY 14048 (716) 366-0040 • 2370 Seneca Street, Buffalo, NY
⭐ Blasdell Pizza Reviews
Rating: 4.4/5 (2,000+ DoorDash reviews, Hamburg store; the Dunkirk store holds 4.5/5 with 3,000+ reviews)
What customers praise: the beef taco salad gets called the best around, the chicken finger pizza with bleu cheese is a repeat favorite, and regulars love the steak and chicken finger combo pies. One longtime reviewer put it simply: fresh, hot and delicious, the go-to for pizza night.
Related Menus
That is the full Blasdell Pizza menu prices breakdown for 2026. If you are anywhere near Western New York, this is the kind of local spot worth a detour: the chicken finger pizza alone justifies the trip, and at $39.36 for a large it is priced to share. My advice? Start with a large specialty pie, add a single order of wings, and let the table fight over the last slice. You will be back.
