Round Table Pizza Secret Menu Guide 2026
Round Table Pizza has no official secret menu, but its create-your-own system unlocks fan-favorite off-menu combos like pepperoni-and-pineapple stuffed Parmesan twists with Polynesian sauce, a double-cheese Maui Zaui, and a well-done bake that crisps up the crust. These Round Table Pizza secret menu hacks are easy to order if you know the exact script.
Look, every chain with a build-your-own option technically has a secret menu, but Round Table is different. This is a chain where regulars have been quietly hacking the menu since the late 50s. I looked into what employees and die-hard fans actually order, and honestly, the best stuff isn’t on the board. Before we dive in, if you haven’t browsed it yet, check the full Round Table Pizza menu with prices so you know the base prices for everything we’re about to customize.
🤫 Does Round Table Pizza Have a Secret Menu?
Short answer: no, there’s no printed secret menu hiding under the register. Longer answer: you don’t need one. Round Table’s ordering system is so customizable that regulars treat the whole menu like a playground. You pick from hand-rolled crusts (rolled fresh in-store daily), sauces like zesty red, creamy garlic, Polynesian and BBQ, and more than 20 toppings. That freedom is exactly why a Round Table Pizza secret menu scene exists at all. Employees have even shared their own shift-meal inventions, which is where the good stuff comes from.
The chain started in 1959 in Menlo Park, California, and still runs 300+ locations mostly across the western US. Because nearly every store is a franchise, one thing to know upfront: customizations depend on the crew working that day. Busy Friday night? Keep it simple. Slow Tuesday afternoon? The staff will usually happily play along.
🔥 Best Round Table Pizza Secret Menu Hacks in 2026
Here are the off-menu Round Table Pizza secret menu items worth trying, with the exact way to ask for each one.
| Hack | What It Is | Price Note |
|---|---|---|
| Stuffed Twists | Pepperoni and pineapple baked inside garlic Parmesan twists, topped with Polynesian sauce | Twist order + toppings |
| Double Maui Zaui | Maui Zaui with extra cheese and double pineapple on Polynesian sauce | ~$2–3 extra |
| Garlic Red Swap | Chicken & Garlic Gourmet built on zesty red sauce instead of creamy garlic | No extra charge |
| Well-Done Bake | Any pizza ordered “well done” for a crispier, golden crust | Free |
| Pesto Twists | Garlic Parmesan twists made with pesto (call ahead to confirm they have it) | Twist order price |
The Stuffed Twist Hack
This one came straight from a Round Table employee who shared it online: ask them to put pepperoni and pineapple into the Parmesan garlic twists and top them with Polynesian sauce before they go into the oven. The twists are already the chain’s most famous appetizer, rolled fresh daily with garlic, a three-cheese blend and Parmesan. Stuffing them turns a great side into something that tastes like a tiny pizza folded inside bread.
How to order: “Can I get an order of garlic Parmesan twists, but can you put pepperoni and pineapple inside them and add some Polynesian sauce on top before baking?”
The Double Maui Zaui
The Maui Zaui is Round Table’s original Polynesian pizza: ham, crisp bacon, juicy pineapple, tomatoes, red and green onions on that sweet-and-tangy Polynesian sauce. Regulars double down by adding extra cheese and extra pineapple. There’s also a Pepperoni Maui Zaui floating around the menu, pepperoni and bacon instead of ham. Want both? Ask for the Maui Zaui with pepperoni added. That’s a personal favorite combo that regulars swear by.
How to order: “Maui Zaui with ham, extra cheese, extra pineapple. And can you add pepperoni on top?”
The Garlic Red Swap
Round Table’s Chicken & Garlic Gourmet is the original chicken-and-white-sauce pizza, but here’s the thing, the creamy garlic sauce can get rich fast. Ask them to build the exact same pizza on zesty red sauce instead. It’s still off the standard script, it cuts the richness, and most stores won’t charge a cent for the swap since sauces are interchangeable in the build system.
How to order: “Chicken & Garlic Gourmet, but can I get it on the zesty red sauce instead of the garlic sauce?”
The Well-Done Bake
The simplest hack of all. Round Table’s crust has that great balance of soft and crunchy, and asking for it “well done” pushes it toward golden and crispy. If you like a crunchier bottom crust on your pizza, this is your move. It costs nothing and works on every pizza, including the King Arthur’s Supreme.
How to order: “Can I get that cooked well done, please?”
📋 How to Order Off-Menu at Round Table Pizza
A few practical tips so your custom order actually comes out right:
Order in-store or by phone. Third-party delivery apps let you customize, but long special instructions often get flattened or ignored. Walking up to the counter (or calling ahead) gets you a real person who can confirm the hack before the pizza goes in the oven.
Keep it to two or three tweaks. Employees are usually happy to help, but a ten-step custom build during the Friday dinner rush is how orders go wrong. One or two swaps on a slow afternoon is the sweet spot.
Ask about Royal Rewards. Round Table runs a rewards program, and regulars who order custom builds a lot rack up points fast. Worth signing up if you’re going to make this a habit.
Watch for seasonal drops. Round Table has been doing limited-time menus lately, like the Dr Pepper BBQ lineup with a Dr Pepper-infused BBQ pizza and wings. Seasonal sauces can be requested as swaps on create-your-own pizzas while they’re around.
Budget honestly. Extra toppings and cheese usually add a couple of dollars each. A heavily customized medium specialty pizza will typically run a few bucks more than the menu price. Check the Round Table Pizza menu for base prices, then plan on roughly $2–3 per premium add-on.
❓ Round Table Pizza Secret Menu FAQs
Does Round Table Pizza have a real secret menu?
No, there’s no official printed secret menu. But the create-your-own system with 20+ toppings and multiple sauces lets you build off-menu combos like stuffed twists and sauce swaps at most locations.
What is the best secret menu hack at Round Table Pizza?
The stuffed twist hack: pepperoni and pineapple baked inside the garlic Parmesan twists with Polynesian sauce on top, shared by a Round Table employee. It’s the closest thing to a famous off-menu item they have.
Can I order secret menu items online?
Yes, but it’s limited. Online and delivery app ordering allow standard customizations, but long special instructions are unreliable. For twist stuffing and unusual swaps, order in-store or call ahead.
Do secret menu customizations cost extra?
Sauce swaps and bake-level changes are usually free. Extra toppings and cheese typically add a couple of dollars each. Prices vary by location since most stores are franchises.
