If you are looking for the dicarlos pizza menu with prices, you landed at the right place.
DiCarlo’s Pizza Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are looking for the dicarlos pizza menu with prices, then you landed at the right place. Here, you can easily explore the DiCarlo’s Pizza menu with prices along with images and full details. All prices are national averages collected from official and verified sources, updated for 2026. DiCarlo’s is famous across the Ohio Valley for one thing: square-cut pizza with a crackly crust, baked with sauce only, then finished with cold provolone cheese piled on after it leaves the oven. It sounds strange. It tastes incredible.
How Much Is the DiCarlos Pizza Menu in 2026?
Short answer: it is one of the cheapest pizza nights in America. A whole 16-cut cheese box lands under $19, and a single slice starts at $2.25. DiCarlo’s does not play the national-chain game of endless topping combos and stuffed crusts. The menu is tight, the prices are honest, and the star of the show is the square pizza box. Below is the full dicarlos pizza menu with 2026 prices, broken down by category. Remember, every DiCarlo’s store is independently owned, so treat these as national averages and expect a buck or two of difference at your local shop.
Signature Square Pizza Boxes (12, 16 & 24-Cut)
Yes, the square boxes are what you came for. DiCarlo’s bakes the crust and sauce in the pan first, then blankets the hot pie with cold provolone and toppings right before boxing it. The cheese melts just enough from the residual heat. It is called Ohio Valley-style pizza, and there is nothing else quite like it. Most boxes come as cheese or pepperoni, and you can add sausage, mushroom or banana peppers for a couple bucks.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Box (12-cut) | Classic square, sauce-baked crust | $14.99 | 200 (est.) |
| Pepperoni Box (12-cut) | Cold provolone, pepperoni on top | $17.49 | 230 (est.) |
| Cheese Box (16-cut) | Feeds 4 to 5 easily | $18.99 | 200 (est.) |
| Pepperoni Box (16-cut) | The most popular box on the menu | $21.99 | 230 (est.) |
| Cheese Box (24-cut) | Party-size tray | $26.99 | 200 (est.) |
| Pepperoni Box (24-cut) | Feeds 7 to 8 hungry people | $30.99 | 230 (est.) |
| Extra Topping (per box) | Sausage, mushroom or banana peppers | $2.50 | 15-40 (est.) |
| Extra Cheese (per box) | More cold provolone, obviously | $3.00 | 60 (est.) |
My pick? The 16-cut pepperoni box. It is the sweet spot for a family of four, and honestly the cold provolone over spicy pepperoni is the combination the chain is famous for. Pro tip: let the box sit for about 10 minutes before opening. The cheese melts gently into the crust and it is a whole different pizza.
Pizza by the Slice: How Much Is a DiCarlo’s Slice?
A slice is the cheapest way to try DiCarlo’s, and it is how most locals eat it. Walk in, grab two squares, and you are out for under six bucks. Many stores run a slice-and-drink special at lunch, and the 4-slice combo is genuinely one of the best lunch deals in the Ohio Valley. Slices are square-cut, obviously. Everything here is square.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheese Slice | Single square-cut slice | $2.25 | 200 (est.) |
| Pepperoni Slice | Square slice with cold cheese and pepperoni | $2.75 | 230 (est.) |
| 4-Slice + Drink Combo | Best lunch deal on the board | $9.99 | 830 (est.) |
Pizza Rolls, Panwiches & Calzones
Do not sleep on the rolls. DiCarlo’s takes its famous pizza dough, stuffs it, folds it and bakes it into handheld form. The pepperoni roll is a West Virginia institution, and the Italian panwich is their take on the sub: pizza dough folded over Italian meats, then pan-fried until golden. It is crunchy, greasy in the best way, and huge.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pepperoni Roll | Stuffed pizza dough, pepperoni and cheese | $5.49 | 320 (est.) |
| Cheese Roll | Simple, cheesy, kid-approved | $4.99 | 290 (est.) |
| Italian Panwich | Pan-fried Italian sub on pizza dough | $11.49 | 720 (est.) |
| Cheese & Pepperoni Calzone | Golden folded calzone, sauce on the side | $10.49 | 780 (est.) |
Hoagies, Salads & Sides
Not in a pizza mood? The hoagies are solid deli-style sandwiches, and the antipasto salad is a sleeper hit. One oddly beloved side: a simple bag of mild peppers. Locals dump them on everything. Ask for extra cheese cups too, because the cold provolone situation deserves more cheese, not less.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Italian Hoagie | Classic deli-style, loaded | $9.99 | 640 (est.) |
| Ham & Provolone Hoagie | Simple and satisfying | $9.49 | 590 (est.) |
| Antipasto Salad | Loaded Italian salad, feeds two | $9.99 | 380 (est.) |
| Garden Salad | Fresh and simple | $7.99 | 220 (est.) |
| Bag of Mild Peppers | Signature side, put them on everything | $3.99 | 30 (est.) |
| Extra Cheese Cup | More cold provolone for dipping | $1.99 | 110 (est.) |
Take N Bake Kits & Drinks
Want the DiCarlo’s experience at home? Several locations sell Take N Bake kits: the par-baked crust and sauce with a bag of cold cheese and toppings, ready for your oven. It is a brilliant souvenir if you are visiting the Valley. Drinks are straightforward, and the Italian ice is a sweet finish on a hot day.
| Item | Details | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take N Bake Kit | Par-baked crust, sauce, cheese and toppings | $12.99 | Varies |
| 2-Liter Soda | To go with the box | $3.49 | Varies |
| Fountain Drink | Large cup | $1.99 | Varies |
| Italian Ice | Sweet finish | $3.49 | 180 (est.) |
DiCarlos Pizza Menu Calories & Nutrition
Here is the honest truth: DiCarlo’s is a small regional chain of independently owned shops, and it does not publish a full nutrition PDF the way the big national brands do. The calorie figures in the tables above are reasonable estimates for dicarlos pizza menu calories based on portion sizes, not lab-tested numbers. A cheese square runs roughly 200 calories, a pepperoni square around 230, and the Italian panwich is the heavyweight at about 720. If you are counting closely, your best move is to call your local store, since recipes are consistent but not centrally published.
| Item | Estimated Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Cheese Slice | ~200 | Lightest pizza option |
| Pepperoni Slice | ~230 | Pepperoni adds about 30 |
| Pepperoni Roll | ~320 | Dense dough, modest size |
| Garden Salad | ~220 | Lightest thing on the menu |
| Italian Panwich | ~720 | Highest-calorie single item |
| Cheese & Pepperoni Calzone | ~780 | Split it with a friend |
All dough is mixed fresh daily in each store, no frozen products are used, and the menu is free of MSG, which is more than you can say for most fast pizza.
DiCarlo’s Pizza Deals & Money-Saving Tips
DiCarlo’s does not have a national app with points and tiers, which is honestly refreshing. Deals are old-school: posted on the window, announced on the local store’s Facebook page, or just built into the everyday pricing. Here is how to pay less:
- Buy the box, not the slices. A 16-cut cheese box at $18.99 works out to about $1.19 per square. Two individual slices cost more per bite.
- Follow your local store on Facebook. Most DiCarlo’s locations are independently owned and post weekend specials and holiday deals there, not on a national site.
- Ask about the lunch combo. The 4-slice plus drink deal is the everyday steal and it is available at most locations.
- Take N Bake for parties. At $12.99 a kit, baking two kits at home costs less than one delivered national-chain pizza.
- Cash discounts. Some Valley locations still knock a little off for cash. It never hurts to ask.
DiCarlo’s Pizza Opening Hours
Hours vary quite a bit because every store is independently owned. The typical pattern is lunch through dinner, with later nights on weekends. Always check your local shop before heading out, especially around holidays.
| Day | Typical Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday to Thursday | 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM |
Some locations open later on Saturdays or close one weekday entirely. The Columbus-area shops tend to run the latest hours, with a few open past midnight on weekends.
About DiCarlo’s Pizza
DiCarlo’s Pizza started in 1945 in Steubenville, Ohio, when Primo DiCarlo came home from World War II with a taste for the pizza he had seen in Italian cafes. The family already ran a beloved Italian bakery, so Primo borrowed their bread recipe, baked it in the bakery’s cookie trays (which is why the pizza is square), and discovered that adding the cheese after the bake kept it fresher and creamier. His brother Galdo opened the second shop in Wheeling, West Virginia, in 1949. Today around 20 DiCarlo’s shops operate across Ohio, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, still family-connected, still making dough fresh daily, and still serving pizza the Ohio Valley way: hot crust, cold cheese.
DiCarlo’s Pizza Menu FAQs
What is the most popular item on the dicarlos pizza menu?
The 16-cut pepperoni box at $21.99. It feeds 4 to 5 people and it is the order the chain is known for: square slices with cold provolone and pepperoni added after the bake.
What are the cheapest items at DiCarlos?
A cheese slice at $2.25 is the cheapest single item, followed by a pepperoni slice at $2.75 and the 4-slice plus drink combo at $9.99, which is the best overall value.
Why is the cheese cold on DiCarlo’s pizza?
That is the signature Ohio Valley style. The crust and sauce are baked in the pan first, then cold provolone and toppings go on the hot pie right before boxing. The cheese melts just enough from the heat and tastes fresher and creamier than fully baked cheese.
Does DiCarlo’s deliver?
Most locations focus on dine-in and carryout. Some shops offer delivery through DoorDash or Uber Eats, but it varies by store since every location is independently owned. Call your local DiCarlo’s to ask.
Does DiCarlo’s publish nutrition information?
Not a full nutrition PDF, no. As a small regional chain, DiCarlo’s does not centrally publish lab-tested nutrition facts. The calorie figures in this article are reasonable estimates based on portion sizes.
How much is the dicarlos pepperoni roll price?
The pepperoni roll costs $5.49 and the cheese roll is $4.99. They are made from the same famous pizza dough, stuffed and baked, and they are a West Virginia staple.
Does DiCarlo’s do catering for parties?
There is no formal national catering program, but the 24-cut boxes at $26.99 to $30.99 are built for groups, and most stores will happily prepare multiple trays for events if you call ahead.
How many DiCarlo’s Pizza locations are there?
Around 20 locations across Ohio, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, including the original 1945 shop in Steubenville, Ohio and the longtime Wheeling, West Virginia stores.
What toppings can I get on a DiCarlo’s pizza?
The classics: pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and banana peppers, plus extra cold provolone. Keep in mind the toppings go on after the bake, so they arrive fresh rather than cooked into the cheese.
Are DiCarlo’s prices the same at every location?
No. Every store is independently owned, so prices vary by location. The figures here are 2026 national averages. Your local shop may be a dollar or two higher or lower.
Prices last verified: October 20, 2026. Source of truth: the official DiCarlo’s Pizza website at dicarlospizza.com, plus verified in-store menus.
📍 Find DiCarlo’s Pizza Near You
⭐ DiCarlo’s Pizza Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.2/5
Customers praise the crackly square crust, the fresh cold provolone, and the old-school value. First-timers are often skeptical about cold cheese, then become converts. The most common complaint is simply that there are not enough locations outside the Ohio Valley.
