Wayback Burgers Secret Menu Guide 2026
The short answer: yes, the wayback burgers secret menu is officially real. The chain runs a members-only secret menu through its Wayback Rewards program, with rotating limited-time items like the Maple Bacon Shake. On top of that, their free toppings and craft-your-own options let you build your own off-menu creations anytime.
Honestly, this one surprised me. Most “secret menus” are just fan theories on Reddit, but Wayback Burgers actually built theirs into the official rewards program. If you are a Wayback Rewards member, you get access to a rotating wayback burgers secret menu of fun, limited-time items that never appear on the regular menu board.
And if you are not a member yet? Don’t worry. Wayback’s whole thing is customization, free toppings, craft-your-own burgers, sandwiches and hot dogs, so there is plenty of off-menu fun available to everyone. If you haven’t checked the regular lineup yet, start with the full Wayback Burgers menu with prices so you know what you are building on.
What Is the Wayback Burgers Secret Menu?
Here is the thing most people get wrong: Wayback’s secret menu isn’t a hidden list of whispered items. It is a members-only feature of the Wayback Rewards program, which the chain launched in April 2024. The idea is simple: fun, limited-time menu items that only rewards members can see and order.
You can access the secret menu wherever you order, through the app, online, at the counter, or on in-store kiosks at select restaurants. New items drop periodically, so what is secret today might be gone next month. That rotation is exactly what makes it fun.
The First Secret Menu Item: Maple Bacon Shake
The debut secret menu item was the Maple Bacon Shake, and yes, it is exactly what it sounds like. Hand-dipped vanilla ice cream blended with milk and maple syrup, then loaded with Wayback crumbled bacon, topped with whipped cream and extra bacon crumbles for good measure.
The suggested price at launch was $6.99, and it was available for a limited time to rewards members only. If a sweet-and-salty combo like that sounds up your alley, keep an eye on the app, the chain tends to bring the crowd favorites back.
How to Order Wayback Burgers Secret Menu Items
Ordering from the secret menu is straightforward, but you do need to be signed up. Here is the exact process:
Step-by-Step
1. Join Wayback Rewards. It is free. Sign up in the Wayback Burgers app or on their website.
2. Check the secret menu section. Open the app or online ordering, logged in, and look for the members-only items.
3. Order it anywhere. Secret items can be ordered in the app, online, at the counter, or on kiosks in select restaurants.
4. Watch for drops. Items rotate, so check back when you are craving something new.
Bonus: members also earn points on every dollar spent, which unlock drinks, fries, tots, shakes, chicken tenders, and even burgers like the Double Bacon Burger and the Cheeeesy Burger. So you are getting the secret stuff and free food over time.
DIY Secret Menu Hacks Anyone Can Order
No app, no problem. Wayback Burgers is basically a secret-menu playground already, because nearly everything is customizable and toppings are free. Here are the off-menu-style builds regulars swear by:
The Nine Patty Burger
This one is technically on the menu at many locations, but most people have never heard of it. Nine beef patties stacked on one bun. Prices swing a lot by location, roughly $28 to $52, and it is the ultimate “did you know?” order to impress your friends.
Cheeeesy Burger Style Customization
Love cheese? Order any double and ask for the Cheeeesy treatment: four slices of melted American cheese and an inverted, grilled, buttered bun. Say it with all four E’s when you order, the staff loves it.
The “Loaded Anything”
Ask for cheese sauce, crispy onion rings, jalapeños, or crumbled bacon added to any burger or chicken sandwich. With free toppings, you can stack a seriously off-menu creation without the price getting crazy.
Secret Shake Combos
The shake lineup rotates through flavors like Oreo, brownie, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Red Velvet. Ask what flavors are in the machine right now and mix two, a brownie plus Oreo blend is a local legend in some stores.
How Much Do Wayback Burgers Secret Menu Items Cost?
Secret menu pricing is mostly straightforward, since most DIY hacks are just customizations of regular items. Here is a quick guide:
| Secret Item / Hack | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Maple Bacon Shake | Official secret menu item, members only, limited time | $6.99* |
| Nine Patty Burger | Nine patties, listed at many locations | $28-$52* |
| Cheeeesy-style upgrade | Extra cheese + inverted grilled bun on any double | +$2-$4* |
| Loaded toppings | Cheese sauce, bacon, onion rings, jalapeños | +$1-$3* |
| Secret shake combo | Two-flavor blend of signature shakes | ~$7-$8* |
*Estimated prices. Wayback Burgers locations are franchises, so prices vary by state and store. Check the Wayback Rewards app or your local store for exact pricing.
Can You Order the Secret Menu Without the App?
For the official secret menu items, no. They are exclusive to Wayback Rewards members, so you need a free account and you order logged in. The good news is it costs nothing and takes about a minute to sign up.
For everything else, the DIY hacks, absolutely. Walk up to any counter and build whatever you want. The staff is used to custom orders, and with the craft-your-own format, your “secret” order is just a regular order with great taste.
FAQs About the Wayback Burgers Secret Menu
Is the Wayback Burgers secret menu real?
Yes. It is an official members-only feature of the Wayback Rewards program, launched in April 2024. The first item was the Maple Bacon Shake, priced at $6.99, and the lineup of limited-time items rotates over time.
How do you order off the Wayback Burgers secret menu?
Join the free Wayback Rewards program, then log in on the app, the website, at the counter, or on a kiosk. Members-only secret items appear when you are signed in.
How much is the nine patty burger at Wayback Burgers?
It varies a lot by franchise location, roughly $28 to $52 based on recent delivery menus. Your local store’s app or menu board will show the exact price.
Can you order secret menu items without joining Wayback Rewards?
Official secret items require a free rewards account. But DIY off-menu builds, like loaded burgers, extra cheese, and custom shake combos, can be ordered by anyone at the counter with no account needed.
Prices last verified: October 18, 2026. Source of truth: the official Wayback Burgers announcement.
