Baked by Melissa Menu USA Prices 2026
If you are hunting down the Baked by Melissa menu, you just found the good stuff. This is the New York bakery that turned one-bite cupcakes into a full-blown obsession, and honestly, once you try the Tie-Dye mini, you will get it. Below you will find every Baked by Melissa menu price for 2026, from the little 6-pack you grab for yourself to the 100-pack that saves the office party. Prices are national averages, and they can shift a bit by location, but this is the real, current picture.
What Does the Baked by Melissa Menu Cost in 2026?
As an Amazon Associate, MenuPrice earns from qualifying purchases.
Short answer: a small treat starts at $16.00, and a party-sized haul tops out at $144.00. The whole menu is built around pack sizes, not single cupcakes, so you pick how many minis you want and then pick your flavors. My pick for a first order? The 25-pack. It is big enough to taste the range, small enough that you will not regret it, and at $43.00 for the Latest and Greatest, it is the sweet spot of the menu.
Here is the full Baked by Melissa menu prices list for 2026. The per-cupcake math is the part most people skip, and it matters: the bigger the pack, the cheaper each bite gets.
| Pack | Details | Price | Per Mini |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pick Your Flavors 6-Pack | Choose any 6 flavors, perfect for one person | $16.00 | about $2.67 |
| Pick Your Flavors 12-Pack | Choose any 12 flavors | $26.00 | about $2.17 |
| Latest & Greatest 12-Pack | Best seller sampler, seasonal flavors included | $24.00 | about $2.00 |
| Latest & Greatest 25-Pack | Best seller, 8 original flavors plus seasonal minis | $43.00 | about $1.72 |
| Fall Favorites 25-Pack | Six sweater-weather flavors | $41.00 | about $1.64 |
| Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack | Your call, all 25 flavors | $46.00 | about $1.84 |
| Vegan 25-Pack | Plant-based minis, same tiny format | $47.00 | about $1.88 |
| Gluten Free 25-Pack | Gluten-free minis for sensitive stomachs | $47.00 | about $1.88 |
| Latest & Greatest 100-Pack | The party pack, best value per cupcake | $139.00 | about $1.39 |
| Pick Your Flavors 100-Pack | 100 minis, every flavor your call | $144.00 | about $1.44 |
What Is in the Latest and Greatest Pack?
Direct answer: the Latest and Greatest is the sampler that built the brand, and it is the pack most first-timers should order. It mixes the 8 must-have original flavors with the current seasonal collection and the Mini of the Month, so you get the classics plus whatever is new. The 25-pack runs $43.00 and it is, hands down, the most-ordered item on the Baked by Melissa menu.
Here is what lands in a Latest and Greatest 25-pack: 2 Tie-Dye, 2 Cookies and Cream, 2 PB and J, 2 Cookie Dough, 2 Chocolate Chip Pancake, 2 Red Velvet, 2 Mint Cookie, 2 Triple Chocolate Fudge, plus 2 of each seasonal flavor and 3 of the Mini of the Month. Seasonal flavors rotate through the year, so the exact mix changes, and that is half the fun.
The Original Greats You Will Keep Coming Back To
These are the flavors that made people line up in New York. Tie-Dye is the icon, vanilla cake with rainbow sugar crystals, light, sweet, and somehow nostalgic even if you never had it as a kid. Red Velvet is rich without being heavy. Triple Chocolate Fudge is the one you eat last, slowly, because you do not want it to end.
| Flavor | What It Tastes Like | Price in a Pack | Calories (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tie-Dye | Vanilla cake, vanilla icing, rainbow sugar crystals | from $16.00 | about 70 |
| Red Velvet | Classic red velvet cake, smooth cream cheese style icing | from $16.00 | about 80 |
| Triple Chocolate Fudge | Chocolate cake, fudge filling, chocolate icing | from $16.00 | about 90 |
| Cookies & Cream | Vanilla cake, cookies and cream icing, cookie pieces | from $16.00 | about 85 |
| Cookie Dough | Chocolate chip cookie dough flavor in mini form | from $16.00 | about 90 |
| PB & J | Peanut butter and jelly, contains nuts | from $16.00 | about 85 |
| Chocolate Chip Pancake | Pancake-inspired cake with chocolate chips | from $16.00 | about 80 |
| Mint Cookie | Cool mint icing with chocolate cookie crunch | from $16.00 | about 75 |
Want the cheapest items at Baked by Melissa? There is no single-cupcake price on the menu, so the cheapest way in is the 6-pack at $16.00. Split it with a friend and you are basically tasting the brand for $8.00 each. Not bad for a New York bakery with this kind of following.
What Seasonal Packs Can You Get Right Now?
Direct answer: the seasonal lineup changes with the calendar, and in fall 2026 the headliners are Fall Favorites and the Halloween packs. Fall Favorites is the cozy one, six flavors made for sweater weather, at $24.00 for 12 or $41.00 for 25. The Halloween packs are the loud, fun ones, and they sell out fast every year.
| Seasonal Pack | Flavors Inside | Price | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fall Favorites | Pumpkin Spice, Chocolate Cookie Cheesecake, Blonde Cookie Dough, Butter Cookie, Red Velvet, Triple Chocolate Fudge | $24.00 | 12-pack |
| Fall Favorites | Same six fall flavors, party size | $41.00 | 25-pack |
| Monster Mash | Spooky Tie Dye, Eyeball, Green Goblin, Bear-ied Alive, Midnight Munchies, Fudge Brownie | $43.00 | 25-pack |
| Hocus Pocus | Latest and Greatest plus Monster Mash combined | $74.00 | 50-pack |
| Football Cupcakes | Latest and Greatest flavors in a football sleeve | $74.00 | 50-pack |
| Diwali Pack | Cardamom Tie Dye, Cardamom Chocolate, Carrot, Pistachio, Coconut, Mango | $43.00 | 25-pack |
| New York Champions | New York Forever, New York Blue, New York Orange cupcakes | $43.00 | 25-pack |
Pumpkin Spice deserves its own shout. Pumpkin-spiced cake, cream cheese frosting, and just enough spice to taste like October without tasting like a candle. If you only order one seasonal flavor, make it that one. And if you are shopping for a Halloween party, the Hocus Pocus 50-pack at $74.00 is the move, especially since the brand has run a free Boo Crew 6-pack bonus with it through October 31, 2026.
Does Baked by Melissa Have Vegan and Gluten-Free Cupcakes?
Direct answer: yes, and they are real menu items, not an afterthought. Vegan minis come in 12-packs for $26.00 and 25-packs for $47.00, and gluten-free minis cost exactly the same. There is also a dedicated gluten-free assortment called Oh My Gluten Free, and a Mac 12-pack for macaron lovers. If you are ordering for a mixed group, this is where Baked by Melissa quietly beats most bakeries, because nobody at the table has to sit out dessert.
| Item | Details | Price | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vegan Latest & Greatest | Plant-based minis, best seller format | $47.00 | 25-pack |
| Vegan 12-Pack | Pick your vegan flavors | $26.00 | 12-pack |
| Gluten Free 12-Pack | Gluten-free minis, pick your flavors | $26.00 | 12-pack |
| Gluten Free 25-Pack | Gluten-free minis, party size | $47.00 | 25-pack |
| The Mac 12-Pack | French macarons, assorted flavors | $30.50 | 12-pack |
| No-Nut Original Greats | Seven signature flavors, no peanut flavors included | $43.00 | 25-pack |
One honest note: everything is baked in a kitchen where nut ingredients are used, so if an allergy is severe, check the allergen details on the official site before you order. The no-nut pack skips peanut flavors, but it is not made in a nut-free facility.
Birthday, Gifts and Party Packs: What Should You Order?
Direct answer: for birthdays, the Birthday Gift Box is the obvious pick, and for big events, the 100-pack dessert table is the best value on the whole menu. The Birthday Gift Box 25-pack costs $51.00 and the 50-pack costs $84.00, and both come gift-ready, which means you are not scrambling for a box and a card at the last minute. Speaking of cards, you can add gold birthday candles for $6.00 and a birthday card for $6.00 at checkout.
| Gift & Party Item | Details | Price | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Birthday Gift Box | Gift-ready box, birthday assortment | $51.00 | 25-pack |
| Birthday Gift Box | Gift-ready box, larger birthday assortment | $84.00 | 50-pack |
| Dessert Table Cupcakes | The full dessert-table spread | $135.00 | 100-pack |
| All The Flavors 50-Pack | Every flavor in one big box | $74.00 | 50-pack |
| All The Flavors 100-Pack | Every flavor, dessert-table size | $139.00 | 100-pack |
| Boo Crew Bundle | Bundle of 4 six-packs, Halloween flavors | $45.00 | 4 x 6-pack |
| Gold Birthday Candles | Add-on for gift orders | $6.00 | set |
| Birthday Card | Add-on for gift orders | $6.00 | each |
| Fiji Water (16.9 oz) | In-store add-on | $4.00 | bottle |
Does Baked by Melissa deliver? Yes, nationwide. Standard shipping runs $15.95 for 2-day delivery and expedited 1-day shipping costs $24.95, and orders ship to all US states including Hawaii and Alaska. If you live near a shop in New York or Boston, in-store pickup skips the shipping fee entirely, which is the smartest saving on this page. Corporate gifting and custom branded packaging are also available for offices, weddings, and big events, and the brand is known for that service, so ask early if your date matters.
Baked by Melissa Nutrition Information
Direct answer: a Baked by Melissa mini is a small, portion-controlled treat, roughly 70 to 90 calories per cupcake depending on the flavor, which is the whole point of the bite-size format. You get the full flavor hit without committing to a full-size cupcake, and that is why people eat three or four and still feel fine about it. The brand lists ingredients and allergen information rather than a full per-flavor nutrition table, so the figures below are typical estimates for bite-size minis, not official lab values.
| Flavor | Estimated Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Tie-Dye | about 70 | Vanilla cake, lightest of the originals |
| Mint Cookie | about 75 | Mint icing, cookie crunch |
| Red Velvet | about 80 | Cream cheese style icing |
| Chocolate Chip Pancake | about 80 | Pancake cake, chocolate chips |
| Cookies & Cream | about 85 | Cookie pieces in icing |
| PB & J | about 85 | Contains peanuts |
| Triple Chocolate Fudge | about 90 | Fudge filling, richest mini |
| Cookie Dough | about 90 | Cookie dough flavor, richest mini |
| Pumpkin Spice | about 75 | Seasonal, cream cheese frosting |
Want a lighter order? Go heavy on Tie-Dye, Mint Cookie, and Pumpkin Spice, skip the fudge-filled ones, and split a 12-pack instead of ordering a 25-pack for yourself. The minis make portion control easy, which is honestly the best nutrition feature on this menu.
Deals & Money-Saving Tips for Baked by Melissa
Direct answer: the best Baked by Melissa deals in 2026 are the 100-pack discount, the Sweet Rewards loyalty program, and pickup instead of shipping. A 20% off code on 100-pack assortments has been running through October 2026, and first-time shoppers have reported 10% off newsletter and welcome offers. Codes change fast and only one code works per order, so check the final total at checkout before you pay.
5 Ways to Pay Less
1. Buy the 100-pack for parties. At about $1.39 per mini, it beats the 25-pack by roughly 30 cents a cupcake, and a 20% off 100-pack code makes it even cheaper.
2. Join Sweet Rewards. The free loyalty program earns 1 point per $1 spent from day one, plus a birthday gift, and higher tiers unlock better perks as your annual spend grows.
3. Pick up in store. If you are near a New York or Boston shop, curbside pickup wipes out the $15.95 shipping fee completely.
4. Refer a friend. Sweet Rewards members can share a referral for $10 off when a friend spends $30 or more, and both sides win.
5. Watch the seasonal drops. Halloween, holiday, and limited-edition packs often come with a free bonus pack, like the free Boo Crew 6-pack with the Hocus Pocus 50-pack through October 31, 2026.
Baked by Melissa Opening Hours
Direct answer: most Baked by Melissa shops are open roughly 9:00 AM to 7:00 PM, with Sunday opening a little later at some locations. Hours vary a lot by shop, because Grand Central runs longer than a neighborhood store, so always check your specific location before you go. The typical neighborhood schedule looks like this:
| Day | Typical Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Thursday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Friday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Saturday | 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Sunday | 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
Looking for a Baked by Melissa near me? The shops cluster in the New York City area, with a Boston presence too, and the flagship spots include Grand Central at 109 E 42nd St and Union Square at 7 E 14th St in Manhattan. Grand Central keeps longer hours, roughly 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM on weekdays and until 11:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, which makes it the late-night cupcake stop.
About Baked by Melissa
Baked by Melissa was founded in 2008 by Melissa Ben-Ishay in New York City, after she was let go from her advertising job and decided to bake what she loved instead. That is a good origin story, and it shows in the product: tiny cupcakes, made by hand, in flavors she develops herself. Today the brand runs 9 retail locations in the New York City area, ships nationwide, and says it has sold more than 500 million cupcakes. It outlasted the whole cupcake craze that swallowed bigger rivals, and the reason is simple, the bite-size format works. You can taste five flavors in one sitting, gift a box without a knife or a fork, and ship a party across the country without a meltdown. Melissa herself went viral on TikTok in 2020 and now has millions of followers, plus bestselling cookbooks, but the cupcakes are still the main event.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Baked by Melissa Menu
What is the most popular item on the Baked by Melissa menu?
The Latest and Greatest 25-pack at $43.00. It mixes the 8 original flavors with seasonal minis and the Mini of the Month, and it is the pack most first-timers order.
What is the cheapest way to order from Baked by Melissa?
The Pick Your Flavors 6-pack at $16.00 is the cheapest way in. For groups, the 100-pack is cheaper per cupcake at about $1.39 each.
Do Baked by Melissa prices vary by location?
Yes, prices can vary slightly by location and channel, in-store versus delivery. The prices on this page are national averages for 2026.
Does Baked by Melissa have vegan and gluten-free cupcakes?
Yes. Vegan and gluten-free minis come in 12-packs for $26.00 and 25-packs for $47.00, plus a Mac 12-pack at $30.50 for macaron fans.
What time does Baked by Melissa open?
Most shops open at 9:00 AM Monday through Saturday and 10:00 AM on Sunday, closing at 7:00 PM. Grand Central runs longer, roughly 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM on weekdays.
Does Baked by Melissa deliver nationwide?
Yes, Baked by Melissa ships to all US states including Hawaii and Alaska. Standard 2-day shipping costs $15.95 and expedited 1-day shipping costs $24.95.
What is the healthiest option at Baked by Melissa?
The lightest minis are Tie-Dye at about 70 calories and Pumpkin Spice at about 75 calories. The bite-size format itself is the portion-control win.
Does Baked by Melissa have deals or coupons?
Yes. Sweet Rewards earns 1 point per $1 spent plus a birthday gift, referrals can earn $10 off, and 20% off 100-pack codes have run through October 2026. Only one code works per order.
Does Baked by Melissa cater parties and events?
Yes, through party packs and corporate gifting. The 100-pack dessert table at $135.00 to $144.00 is the go-to for weddings, office parties, and baby showers, with custom branded packaging available.
Is there a Baked by Melissa secret menu?
There is no official secret menu. The closest thing is the rotating Mini of the Month and the limited-edition seasonal drops, which change through the year and sell out fast.
Prices last verified: October 25, 2026. Source of truth: the official Baked by Melissa menu at bakedbymelissa.com.
📍 Find Baked by Melissa Near You
⭐ Baked by Melissa Google Reviews
Google Rating: 4.2/5
Customers praise the cute packaging, the friendly staff, and the perfect sweetness of the minis. The Tie-Dye and Red Velvet flavors come up again and again in reviews, and shoppers love how gift-ready the boxes are. The most common complaint? The minis are small, which is fair, they are one bite by design, so order a bigger pack than you think you need.
🔗 Related Menus
So, that is the full Baked by Melissa menu for 2026, every pack, every flavor family, and every deal worth knowing. My honest recommendation: start with the Latest and Greatest 25-pack, grab a Fall Favorites 12-pack while it is around, and save the 100-pack for the party you are definitely going to throw once your friends taste these.
